80		Needful Things (Crime, Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1993)
78		Hush...Hush, Sweet Charlotte (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1964)
70		The Amityville Horror (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
67		Unearthed (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 2007)
65		The Prowler (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1981)
64		Revenge of the Creature (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1955)
62		Just Before Dawn (Horror, Thriller, 1981)
60		Near Dark (Action, Crime, Drama, Horror, 1987)
59		Venom (Horror, 2005)
57		Trauma (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1993)
57		The Skeleton Key (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2005)
57		Without Warning (Sci-Fi, Horror, 1980)
57		The Fog (Fantasy, Horror, 1980)
55		The Wild Man of the Navidad (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2008)
54		DeepStar Six (Action, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1989)
54		Wolves (Action, Horror, 2014)
54		Godzilla, King of the Monsters! (Action, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1956)
54		Eaten Alive (Horror, Thriller, 1976)
52		Twin Peaks: The Missing Pieces (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2014)
52		Angel Heart (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1987)
52		The Call of Cthulhu (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
52		Bug (Sci-Fi, Horror, Mystery, 1975)
50		Friday the 13th Part 2 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1981)
50		The Pit (Horror, Mystery, 1981)
49		Green Room (Crime, Horror, Music, 2015)
49		The Curse of Frankenstein (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1957)
49		Throwback (Action, Adventure, Horror, 2014)
49		Island of Terror (Horror, 1966)
49		Altered (Horror, Sci-Fi, Thriller, 2006)
49		Split Second (Action, Crime, Horror, 1992)
49		Swamp Devil (Horror, 2008)
49		Graveyard Shift (Horror, 1990)
49		Creature from the Black Lagoon (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1954)
49		Harbinger Down (Horror, Sci-Fi, 2015)
48		Five Million Years to Earth (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 1967)
48		The Picture of Dorian Gray (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1945)
48		The New Kids (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1985)
47		Phantom of the Opera (Drama, Horror, Music, 1943)
47		The Car (Action, Horror, Mystery, 1977)
47		The Gift (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2000)
47		Deliver Us from Evil (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
47		The Curse of the Cat People (Drama, Horror, 1944)
47		Godzilla vs. Biollante (Action, Drama, Horror, 1989)
47		Chernobyl Diaries (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 2012)
45		The Mothman Prophecies (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2002)
45		Dead Men Walk (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1943)
45		The Territory (Drama, Horror, 1981)
45		The Haunting of Julia (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1977)
45		The Keeper (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1976)
45		Schizo (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1976)
45		Mary, Mary, Bloody Mary (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1975)
44		Coma (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1978)
44		Deep Rising (Action, Adventure, Horror, 1998)
44		Blood Stalkers (Horror, 1976)
44		Nightbreed (Action, Fantasy, Horror, 1990)
44		The Creature Walks Among Us (Horror, 1956)
44		Shark Night 3D (Horror, Thriller, 2011)
44		30 Days of Night (Horror, 2007)
44		The Mist (Horror, Sci-Fi, 2007)
44		The Plague of the Zombies (Fantasy, Horror, 1966)
44		eXistenZ (Horror, Sci-Fi, Thriller, 1999)
43		Child's Play (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1972)
43		A Reflection of Fear (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1972)
43		Night of Dark Shadows (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1971)
43		The Legend of Boggy Creek (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1972)
43		The Other (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1972)
43		An Evening of Edgar Allan Poe (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1970)
42		The Boy (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2016)
42		Dead End (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2003)
42		Roar (Adventure, Horror, Thriller, 1981)
42		Carrie (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2013)
42		The Hound of the Baskervilles (Horror, Mystery, 1959)
42		The City of the Dead (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1960)
42		Dream No Evil (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1970)
42		The Barber (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 2002)
42		Scream (Horror, Mystery, 1996)
42		Night of the Living Dead (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1968)
42		Homecoming (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2009)
42		Harvest Lake (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2016)
42		The Last Exorcism (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2010)
42		Crawlspace (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 2012)
42		Sinister (Horror, Mystery, 2012)
41		Doctor Faustus (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1967)
41		The Birds (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1963)
41		Twilight Zone: The Movie (Fantasy, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1983)
41		The Man Who Laughs (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1928)
40		Dorothy Mills (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2008)
40		The Stranger (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2014)
40		Mystery of Edwin Drood (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1935)
40		The Invisible Man Returns (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1940)
40		Visitors (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2003)
40		Curse of the Fly (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1965)
40		The Torturer (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2008)
40		Last Kind Words (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2012)
40		The Bleeding House (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2011)
40		Ragini MMS (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2011)
40		Yao ye hui lang (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2003)
40		The Harvest (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2013)
40		Mr. Sardonicus (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1961)
40		Lake Mungo (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2008)
40		Trauma (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2004)
40		Alien (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1979)
40		Premature Burial (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1962)
40		Amnesiac (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2014)
40		The Vampire Bat (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1933)
40		Phantom Ship (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1935)
40		Rowing with the Wind (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1988)
40		The Echo (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2008)
40		Paranoiac (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1963)
40		The Uninvited (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2009)
40		Jacob's Ladder (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1990)
40		Seazone (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2010)
40		The Rite (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2011)
40		The Guardian (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1990)
40		The Color Out of Space (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2010)
40		Roadside (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2013)
40		The Vanishing (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1993)
40		The Killing Jar (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1997)
40		Red Lights (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2012)
40		Secret of the Blue Room (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1933)
40		Last Woman on Earth (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1960)
40		Deadly Sins (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1995)
40		The Haunting in Connecticut (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2009)
40		Stonehearst Asylum (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2014)
40		Haunted Traxx (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2009)
40		Book of Blood (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2009)
40		The Bunker (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2001)
40		The Moth Diaries (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2011)
40		Absentia (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2011)
40		Razorback (Horror, Thriller, 1984)
40		After.Life (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2009)
40		Chamber of Horrors (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1940)
40		Something Wicked (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2014)
40		In the Winter Dark (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1998)
40		Danika (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2006)
40		Circle (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2015)
40		Static (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2012)
40		Gui si (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2006)
40		Sympathy (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2007)
40		House of 9 (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
40		Backtrack (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2015)
40		Isle of the Dead (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1945)
40		Pay the Ghost (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2015)
40		The Return of Dracula (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1958)
40		The Maid (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
40		Cry_Wolf (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
40		The Seventh Victim (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1943)
40		Goddess of Love (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2015)
40		Frenchman's Farm (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1987)
40		Three Cases of Murder (Crime, Mystery, Drama, Horror, 1955)
40		The Living and the Dead (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2006)
40		The Undying Monster (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1942)
40		The Inheritance (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1947)
40		The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
40		Half Light (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2006)
40		Fog Island (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1945)
40		10 Cloverfield Lane (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2016)
40		The Forgotten (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2004)
40		Creature (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1985)
40		Apprentice to Murder (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1988)
40		Condemned to Live (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1935)
40		Ghost Son (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2007)
40		When the Bough Breaks (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2016)
40		Thr3e (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2006)
40		The Haunting in Connecticut 2: Ghosts of Georgia (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2013)
40		First Born (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2007)
40		White Noise (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
40		One Point O (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2004)
40		The Invitation (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2015)
40		Boogeyman (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
40		Hide and Seek (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
39		Zibahkhana (Horror, Thriller, 2007)
39		Village of the Damned (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1960)
39		Godzilla vs. Destoroyah (Action, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1995)
39		The Thing from Another World (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1951)
39		Hellraiser (Fantasy, Horror, 1987)
39		Abominable (Horror, Thriller, 2006)
39		Don't Be Afraid of the Dark (Fantasy, Horror, Thriller, 2010)
39		The Creeper (Adventure, Horror, Thriller, 1977)
39		The Tingler (Horror, 1959)
39		The Puppet Masters (Horror, Sci-Fi, Thriller, 1994)
39		The Mummy's Curse (Fantasy, Horror, Thriller, 1944)
39		Fiend Without a Face (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1958)
39		Tarantula (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1955)
39		Aliens vs. Predator: Requiem (Action, Horror, Sci-Fi, 2007)
39		X the Unknown (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1956)
37		The Lost (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2006)
37		Ruby (Drama, Horror, 1977)
37		Strangler of the Swamp (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1946)
37		The Forest (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2016)
37		Werewolf of London (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1935)
37		Nomads (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1986)
37		Whisper (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2007)
37		The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2013)
37		Night Monster (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1942)
37		Kongo (Drama, Horror, 1932)
37		Antichrist (Drama, Horror, 2009)
37		Strait-Jacket (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1964)
37		Dark Was the Night (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2014)
37		Svengali (Drama, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1931)
37		The Flesh and the Fiends (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1960)
37		The Carrier (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1988)
37		Saw VI (Horror, Mystery, 2009)
37		Backcountry (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2014)

Notes: Movies similar to Creature from Black Lake, Movies like Creature from Black Lake, Drama, Horror, Mystery, Joy N. Houck Jr., Jack Elam, Dub Taylor, Dennis Fimple, John David Carson, Films, Video, Movie Similarities