40		Daffy Duck's Quackbusters (Animation, Comedy, Family, Horror, 1988)
40		Frankenweenie (Animation, Comedy, Family, Horror, 2012)
35		Believe (Family, Horror, 2000)
31		The Black Cat (Comedy, Horror, Mystery, 1941)
30		The Witches (Adventure, Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1990)
30		¡Vampiros en La Habana! (Animation, Comedy, Horror, 1985)
30		The Monster Squad (Action, Comedy, Family, Horror, 1987)
30		Frankenstein and Me (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, Horror, 1996)
30		Ngo joh ngan gin do gwai (Comedy, Family, Horror, 2002)
30		Goosebumps (Adventure, Comedy, Family, Horror, 2015)
30		The Haunted Mansion (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, Horror, 2003)
30		Dead Fury (Animation, Action, Comedy, Horror, 2008)
30		Hair High (Animation, Comedy, Horror, 2004)
30		Scooby-Doo 2: Monsters Unleashed (Adventure, Comedy, Family, Horror, 2004)
26		Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1948)
25		Abbott and Costello Meet the Killer, Boris Karloff (Comedy, Horror, Mystery, 1949)
25		Harold's Going Stiff (Comedy, Horror, 2011)
25		Master Minds (Horror, Comedy, 1949)
25		The Feathered Serpent (Comedy, Crime, Horror, 1948)
25		Revenge of Billy the Kid (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1992)
25		Things Happen at Night (Comedy, Horror, 1948)
25		Sightseers (Adventure, Comedy, Crime, Horror, 2012)
24		Abbott and Costello Meet the Invisible Man (Comedy, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1951)
23		The Bowery Boys Meet the Monsters (Horror, Comedy, Sci-Fi, 1954)
23		One Body Too Many (Comedy, Horror, Mystery, 1944)
23		Gildersleeve's Ghost (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1944)
23		Ghost Catchers (Comedy, Horror, Music, 1944)
23		Black Magic (Comedy, Crime, Drama, Horror, 1944)
23		Zombies on Broadway (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1945)
23		Scared Stiff (Comedy, Horror, Musical, 1953)
23		Abbott and Costello Meet Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (Comedy, Horror, Mystery, 1953)
22		Abbott and Costello Meet the Mummy (Action, Adventure, Comedy, Horror, 1955)
22		The Hidden Hand (Comedy, Horror, Mystery, 1942)
22		The Boogie Man Will Get You (Comedy, Horror, 1942)
22		Revenge of the Zombies (Adventure, Comedy, Horror, 1943)
22		The Mad Doctor of Market Street (Comedy, Drama, Horror, 1942)
22		Francis in the Haunted House (Comedy, Horror, Fantasy, 1956)
21		You'll Find Out (Comedy, Horror, Musical, 1940)
21		Tucker and Dale vs Evil (Comedy, Horror, 2010)
21		Zombieland (Adventure, Comedy, Horror, 2009)
21		The Ghost Breakers (Comedy, Horror, Mystery, 1940)
21		Charlie Chan at Treasure Island (Comedy, Crime, Horror, 1939)
21		Bride of Frankenstein (Comedy, Drama, Horror, 1935)
21		What We Do in the Shadows (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2014)
21		The Ghost Train (Comedy, Horror, 1941)
21		Spooks Run Wild (Horror, Comedy, 1941)
21		The Invisible Man (Comedy, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1933)
21		Army of Darkness (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1992)
21		Invasion of the Saucer Men (Comedy, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1957)
21		An American Werewolf in London (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1981)
21		Shaun of the Dead (Comedy, Horror, 2004)
21		Evil Dead II (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1987)
21		Braindead (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1992)

Notes: Movies similar to The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad, Movies like The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad, Animation, Comedy, Family, Horror, James Algar, Clyde Geronimi, Jack Kinney, Bing Crosby, Basil Rathbone, Eric Blore, John McLeish, Films, Video, Movie Similarities