60		Odd Thomas (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2013)
55		Coyote (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2014)
51		Zus & zo (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2001)
51		An American Werewolf in London (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1981)
49		Monty Python and the Holy Grail (Adventure, Comedy, Fantasy, 1975)
49		Schizopolis (Comedy, Fantasy, Mystery, 1996)
47		Elf (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2003)
47		Rhinoceros (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 1974)
46		Being John Malkovich (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 1999)
46		The Price of Milk (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2000)
46		Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1948)
46		The Three Trials (Comedy, Crime, Fantasy, 2006)
45		The Fall of the Louse of Usher: A Gothic Tale for the 21st Century (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2002)
45		House (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1986)
45		Gory Gory Hallelujah (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2003)
45		Lucky (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2004)
45		Seed of Chucky (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2004)
45		Dead & Breakfast (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2004)
44		Santa's Slay (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2005)
44		Boy Eats Girl (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2005)
44		A Life Less Ordinary (Comedy, Crime, Fantasy, 1997)
44		The Convent (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2000)
44		Die You Zombie Bastards! (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2005)
44		The Horror of H.P. Lovecraft (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2006)
44		Yonimo kimyô na monogatari - Eiga no tokubetsu hen (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2000)
44		The League of Gentlemen's Apocalypse (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2005)
43		Idle Hands (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1999)
43		Bride of Chucky (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1998)
43		The Wolves of Kromer (Fantasy, Horror, Comedy, 1998)
43		Make-Out with Violence (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2008)
43		Gingerdead Man 2: Passion of the Crust (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2008)
43		Damned on Earth (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2014)
43		Teeth (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2007)
42		Brewster McCloud (Comedy, Fantasy, 1970)
42		Rubber (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2010)
42		The Revenant (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2009)
42		Con la muerte en los 2 tacones (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2009)
42		Bordello of Blood (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1996)
42		An American Werewolf in Paris (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1997)
42		The Frighteners (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1996)
42		Jennifer's Body (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2009)
41		Evil Dead II (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1987)
41		Click (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2006)
41		What We Do in the Shadows (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2014)
41		Twixt (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2011)
41		Vampire in Brooklyn (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1995)
41		Rumpelstiltskin (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1995)
41		Cemetery Man (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1994)
41		Leprechaun 2 (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1994)
41		Braindead (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1992)
41		Night of the Demons 2 (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1994)
41		Dark Shadows (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2012)
41		Potpourri (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2011)
41		Regissören (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2011)
41		Army of Darkness (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1992)
41		Dracula: Dead and Loving It (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1995)
40		Gremlins (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1984)
40		Leprechaun (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1993)
40		Ghoulies (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1984)
40		Transylvania 6-5000 (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1985)
40		Waxwork II: Lost in Time (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1992)
40		The Ghost Goes West (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1935)
40		The Raven (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1963)
40		Troll (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1986)
40		Saturday the 14th (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1981)
40		Full Moon High (Comedy, Horror, Fantasy, 1981)
40		Francis in the Haunted House (Comedy, Horror, Fantasy, 1956)
40		Creepshow (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1982)
40		My Boyfriend's Back (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1993)
40		The Monster Club (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1981)
40		Death Becomes Her (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1992)
40		Night of the Demons (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1988)
40		Nightmare Sisters (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1988)
40		Gate 2: The Trespassers (Fantasy, Horror, Comedy, 1990)
40		The Refrigerator (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1991)
40		Paranormal Bad Trip 3D (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2014)
40		Tales from the Gimli Hospital (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1988)
40		Gremlins 2: The New Batch (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1990)
40		Gildersleeve's Ghost (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1944)
40		Tales from the Darkside: The Movie (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1990)
40		Arachnophobia (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1990)
40		Zombies on Broadway (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1945)
40		Repossessed (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1990)
40		High Spirits (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1988)
40		Krampus (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2015)
40		Freddy's Dead: The Final Nightmare (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1991)
40		Spooked in Bridgewater (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2015)
40		House II: The Second Story (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1987)
40		The Lost Boys (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1987)
40		Creepshow 2 (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1987)
40		My Demon Lover (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1987)
40		Children Shouldn't Play with Dead Things (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1972)
40		Revenge of Billy the Kid (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1992)
40		The Witches of Eastwick (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1987)
37		Du Barry Was a Lady (Comedy, Fantasy, Musical, 1943)
37		Tom Dick and Harry (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1941)
37		Coffka (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2009)
36		Interstate 60: Episodes of the Road (Adventure, Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2002)
36		On the Nose (Comedy, Fantasy, 2001)
35		The Inner Life of Martin Frost (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2007)
35		My Name Is Bruce (Comedy, Fantasy, 2007)
34		Here Comes the Bride (Comedy, Fantasy, 2010)
34		Highlander (Action, Adventure, Fantasy, 1986)
33		Up There (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2012)
33		It's Such a Beautiful Day (Animation, Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2012)
33		Vanilla Sky (Fantasy, Mystery, Romance, 2001)
33		Miracle in Milan (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 1951)
32		Gagamboy (Action, Comedy, Fantasy, 2004)
32		If Only (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2004)
32		Ella Enchanted (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2004)
32		Mah nakorn (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2004)
32		Fat Albert (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2004)
32		Shortcut to Happiness (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2003)
32		P.S. (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2004)
32		A Day Without a Mexican (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2004)
32		Les visiteurs (Comedy, Fantasy, Sci-Fi, 1993)
32		13 Going on 30 (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2004)
32		The Santa Clause 2 (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2002)
32		Like Mike (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2002)
32		S1m0ne (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2002)
32		Cultivision (Collapsing Stars) (Sci-Fi, Comedy, Fantasy, 2002)
32		The Hot Chick (Comedy, Fantasy, 2002)
32		Bubba Ho-Tep (Comedy, Fantasy, Mystery, 2002)
32		Don't Ask Don't Tell (Comedy, Fantasy, Sci-Fi, 2002)
32		Alice (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1990)
32		The Milagro Beanfield War (Comedy, Fantasy, Drama, 1988)
32		Reflections of Evil (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2002)
32		Baby of the Family (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2002)
32		Jam Films (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2002)
32		The Medallion (Action, Comedy, Fantasy, 2003)
32		Swing (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2003)
32		Super Fuzz (Action, Comedy, Fantasy, 1980)
32		The Haunted Mansion (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2003)
32		Freaky Friday (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2003)
32		Bulletproof Monk (Action, Comedy, Fantasy, 2003)
32		Peak Experience (Adventure, Comedy, Fantasy, 2003)
32		Screen Door Jesus (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2003)
32		Henry X (Adventure, Comedy, Fantasy, 2003)
32		Captain Barbell (Adventure, Comedy, Fantasy, 2003)
32		Nothing (Comedy, Fantasy, 2003)
32		Bloom (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2008)
32		Premature (Comedy, Fantasy, 2014)
32		Stranger Than Fiction (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2006)
31		One Hell of a Guy (Romance, Comedy, Fantasy, 2000)
31		What Women Want (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2000)
31		The Family Man (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2000)
31		Little Nicky (Comedy, Fantasy, 2000)
31		Bedazzled (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2000)
31		How the Grinch Stole Christmas (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2000)
31		Sita Sings the Blues (Animation, Comedy, Fantasy, 2008)
31		Camera (Adventure, Comedy, Fantasy, 2000)
31		Woman on Top (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2000)
31		South Park: Bigger Longer & Uncut (Animation, Comedy, Fantasy, 1999)
31		The Specials (Action, Comedy, Fantasy, 2000)
31		Nanny McPhee (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2005)
31		Citizen Toxie: The Toxic Avenger IV (Action, Comedy, Fantasy, 2000)
31		Radio Free Steve (Adventure, Comedy, Fantasy, 2000)
31		Naked Wishes (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2000)
31		Monkeybone (Animation, Comedy, Fantasy, 2001)
31		Down to Earth (Comedy, Fantasy, 2001)
31		Dr. Dolittle 2 (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2001)
31		No Such Thing (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2001)
31		Just Visiting (Comedy, Fantasy, Sci-Fi, 2001)
31		WillFull (Comedy, Fantasy, 2001)
31		Escanaba in da Moonlight (Comedy, Fantasy, 2001)
31		Shallow Hal (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2001)
31		Delivering Milo (Comedy, Fantasy, 2001)
31		The Adventures of Cinderella's Daughter (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2000)
31		Kate & Leopold (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2001)
31		How High (Comedy, Fantasy, 2001)
31		Black Knight (Adventure, Comedy, Fantasy, 2001)
31		Hwasango (Action, Comedy, Fantasy, 2001)
31		Picking Up the Pieces (Comedy, Fantasy, 2000)
31		The Kid (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2000)
31		The Science of Sleep (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2006)
31		Pizza Girl (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2005)
31		Wristcutters: A Love Story (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2006)
31		Four Eyed Monsters (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2005)
31		Aquamarine (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2006)
31		Khottabych (Adventure, Comedy, Fantasy, 2006)
31		Coming Soon (Comedy, Fantasy, 2006)
31		The Shaggy Dog (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2006)
31		Cross-Eyed Waltz (Adventure, Comedy, Fantasy, 2005)
31		Love & Plutonium (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2005)
31		GamerZ (Comedy, Fantasy, 2005)
31		Mga pusang gala (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2005)
31		Just Like Heaven (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2005)
31		r3tual (Adventure, Comedy, Fantasy, 2005)
31		Es ist ein Elch entsprungen (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2005)
31		Bewitched (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2005)
31		Yours, Mine & Ours (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2005)
31		Penelope (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2006)
31		Just My Luck (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2006)
31		1st Bite (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2006)
31		It's a Boy Girl Thing (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2006)
31		Brand Upon the Brain! A Remembrance in 12 Chapters (Comedy, Fantasy, 2006)
31		The Play-Station Killed the Puppet (Comedy, Fantasy, 2010)
31		The Nine Lives of Tomas Katz (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2000)
31		Charlotte's Web (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2006)
31		Cineme' Fabrique No. 1 (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2006)
31		The Importance of Being Russell (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2006)
31		Two Front Teeth (Action, Comedy, Fantasy, 2006)

Notes: Movies similar to New Guy, Movies like New Guy, Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, Bilge Ebiri, Kelly Miller, Scott Janes, Jonathan Uffelman, Johnny Ray, Films, Video, Movie Similarities