97		25 to Life (Windows, 2006)
97		Max Payne (Windows, 2001)
95		Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne (Windows, 2003)
90		The Untouchables (DOS, 1989)
82		Blind Shot: Assassin's Confession (Windows, 2009)
82		District Wars (Windows, 2009)
74		Made Man: Confessions of the Family Blood (Windows, 2007)
71		Prototype 2 (Windows, 2012)
65		Prototype (Windows, 2009)
57		Hitman: Blood Money (Windows, 2006)
56		Total Overdose: A Gunslinger's Tale in Mexico (Windows, 2007)
55		Hitman 2: Silent Assassin (Windows, 2002)
54		Kane & Lynch: Dead Men (Windows, 2007)
53		Kane & Lynch 2: Dog Days (Windows, 2010)
53		Hitman: Codename 47 (Windows, 2000)
52		Predator 2 (DOS, 1991)
52		Hitman 2 (Windows, 2018)
52		Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Conviction (Windows, 2010)
51		Far Cry 5 (Windows, 2018)
50		Hotline Miami 2: Wrong Number (Windows, 2015)
47		Stranglehold (Windows, 2007)
47		El Matador (Windows, 2006)
46		The Shield: The Game (Windows, 2007)
45		Peter Jackson's King Kong: The Official Game of the Movie (Windows, 2005)
45		American McGee presents Bad Day LA (Windows, 2006)
45		NARC (Windows, 2008)
44		Dead to Rights (Windows, 2003)
44		Freedom Fighters (Windows, 2003)
43		Just Cause 2 (Windows, 2010)
43		Turning Point: Fall of Liberty (Windows, 2008)
43		RoboCop 2D (Windows, 2004)
43		Bad Boys: Miami Takedown (Windows, 2004)
43		Alone in the Dark (Windows, 2008)
43		Ghostbusters: The Video Game (Windows, 2009)
42		RoboCop (Windows, 2003)
41		Command & Conquer: Renegade (Windows, 2002)
41		Hotline Miami (Windows, 2012)
41		Adam Blaster: Atomic Enforcer (Windows, 2002)
41		2025: Battle for Fatherland (Windows, 2010)
41		Just Cause 3 (Windows, 2015)
40		Metro-Police (Windows, 1998)

Notes: Games similar to True Crime: New York City, Games like True Crime: New York City, Luxoflux Corp., Z-Axis, Ltd., Aspyr Media, Inc., Windows, Action, North America, Shooter, Crime, Behind view, Open world, Free-roaming, Sandbox action and driving, Black, City - New York, Law enforcement, PC, Game Similarities.