47		HardBall III (DOS, 1992)
44		HardBall 4 (DOS, 1994)
44		R.B.I. Baseball 2 (DOS, 1991)
44		Bo Jackson Baseball (DOS, 1991)
43		Triple Play 97 (Windows, 1996)
43		ESPN Baseball Tonight (DOS, 1994)
43		MVP Baseball 2005 (Windows, 2005)
42		MVP Baseball 2004 (Windows, 2004)
42		MVP Baseball 2003 (Windows, 2003)
41		Super Mega Baseball: Extra Innings (Windows, 2015)
41		Triple Play 97 (DOS, 1996)
40		Super Mega Baseball 2 (Windows, 2018)
40		Championship Baseball (DOS, 1986)
40		HardBall 6 (Windows, 1998)
40		Triple Play 2000 (Windows, 1999)
40		HardBall! (DOS, 1987)

Notes: Games similar to Catch: If You Can!, Games like Catch: If You Can!, DOS, Sports, Behind view, Baseball, PC, Game Similarities.