56		Angel and the Badman (Romance, Western, 1947)
53		El Dorado (Drama, Romance, Western, 1966)
50		The Westerner (Drama, Romance, Western, 1940)
47		Will Penny (Romance, Western, 1967)
47		The Last Sunset (Drama, Romance, Western, 1961)
45		5 Card Stud (Mystery, Romance, Western, 1968)
43		Red River (Action, Adventure, Romance, 1948)
43		The Big Country (Romance, Western, 1958)
42		The Train Robbers (Comedy, Romance, Western, 1973)
42		Firecreek (Romance, Western, 1968)
42		The Cheyenne Social Club (Comedy, Romance, Western, 1970)
40		Dark Command (Drama, Romance, Western, 1940)
39		Rio Grande (Romance, Western, 1950)
38		The Shootist (Drama, Romance, Western, 1976)
37		The Ballad of Little Jo (Drama, Romance, Western, 1993)
37		The Big Trail (Adventure, Western, Romance, 1930)
37		Decision at Sundown (Romance, Western, 1957)
37		North to Alaska (Comedy, Romance, Western, 1960)
37		Rio Lobo (Adventure, Western, Romance, 1970)
37		Along Came Jones (Comedy, Romance, Western, 1945)
37		Open Range (Drama, Romance, Western, 2003)
37		Invitation to a Gunfighter (Romance, Western, 1964)
37		McLintock! (Comedy, Romance, Western, 1963)
35		Silverado (Action, Crime, Drama, Romance, 1985)
34		The Horse Soldiers (Adventure, Romance, War, 1959)
34		Along the Great Divide (Adventure, Romance, Western, 1951)
34		The Furies (Drama, Romance, Western, 1950)
34		Rawhide (Drama, Romance, Western, 1951)
33		The Shepherd of the Hills (Adventure, Drama, Romance, 1941)
33		Son of Paleface (Comedy, Romance, Western, 1952)
33		Spellbound (Film-Noir, Mystery, Romance, 1945)
32		The Tall T (Romance, Thriller, Western, 1957)
32		Pardners (Comedy, Romance, Western, 1956)
32		The Horse Whisperer (Drama, Romance, Western, 1998)
32		River of No Return (Adventure, Romance, Western, 1954)
32		Warlock (Romance, Western, 1959)
32		Rancho Deluxe (Comedy, Romance, Western, 1975)
32		From Noon Till Three (Comedy, Romance, Western, 1976)
32		The Iron Horse (History, Romance, Western, 1924)
32		Kings Row (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 1942)
32		The Hi-Lo Country (Drama, Romance, Western, 1998)
32		Man of the West (Drama, Romance, Western, 1958)
32		The Far Country (Romance, Western, 1954)
32		The Body (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2001)
32		Sherlock Holmes Faces Death (Crime, Mystery, Romance, 1943)
32		Love Letters (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 1945)
31		Deadline at Dawn (Film-Noir, Mystery, Romance, 1946)
31		Big Jim McLain (Crime, Drama, History, Romance, 1952)
31		Duel in the Sun (Drama, Romance, Western, 1946)
30		Pursuit to Algiers (Adventure, Crime, Mystery, Romance, 1945)
30		Bend of the River (Action, Adventure, Romance, 1952)
30		Trouble Along the Way (Comedy, Drama, Romance, 1953)
30		The Man from Colorado (Romance, Western, 1948)
30		The Comancheros (Action, Western, Adventure, Romance, 1961)
29		Across the Wide Missouri (Adventure, Romance, Western, 1951)
29		Shane (Drama, Romance, Western, 1953)
29		The Girl Was Young (Crime, Mystery, Romance, 1937)
29		A Guy Named Joe (Drama, Romance, War, 1943)
29		Dragonwyck (Drama, Thriller, Mystery, Romance, 1946)
29		Topper Returns (Comedy, Fantasy, Mystery, Romance, 1941)
29		Algiers (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 1938)
29		The Quick and the Dead (Action, Romance, Thriller, 1995)
29		Vertigo (Mystery, Romance, Thriller, 1958)
29		Broken Arrow (Drama, Romance, Western, 1950)
29		The Wind (Drama, Romance, Western, 1928)
29		The Octagon (Action, Drama, Romance, 1980)
29		Bridge of Dragons (Action, Romance, Sci-Fi, 1999)
29		The Fighting Seabees (Drama, Romance, War, 1944)
29		Tom Horn (Crime, Drama, Romance, 1980)
29		My Favorite Brunette (Comedy, Crime, Mystery, Romance, 1947)
28		Darr (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 1993)
28		The Illusionist (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2006)
28		Charade (Comedy, Mystery, Romance, 1963)
28		It's a Wonderful World (Comedy, Crime, Mystery, Romance, 1939)
28		The Apartment (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 1996)
28		Survive Style 5+ (Fantasy, Mystery, Romance, 2004)
28		Lovers of the Arctic Circle (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 1998)
28		Without Reservations (Comedy, Romance, 1946)
28		My Cousin Rachel (Mystery, Romance, Drama, 1952)
28		Reunion in France (Drama, Romance, War, 1942)
28		Sands of Iwo Jima (Action, Drama, War, Romance, 1949)
28		The Ex-Mrs. Bradford (Comedy, Mystery, Romance, 1936)
28		Atonement (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2007)
28		Pursued (Drama, Romance, Thriller, 1947)
28		The Red Violin (Drama, Romance, Mystery, 1998)
28		The Big Trees (Action, Romance, Western, 1952)
27		Solaris (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2002)
27		Original Sin (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2001)
27		Birth (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2004)
27		Look Both Ways (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2005)
27		Urban Cowboy (Drama, Romance, Western, 1980)
27		The Morning After (Crime, Mystery, Romance, 1986)
27		Dream Lover (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 1993)
27		Sommersby (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 1993)
27		Boxing Helena (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 1993)
27		Enduring Love (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2004)
27		Physical Evidence (Crime, Mystery, Romance, 1989)
27		Lantana (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2001)
27		Wicker Park (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2004)
27		Siesta (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 1987)
27		Gone, But Not Forgotten (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2003)
27		Nadine (Comedy, Mystery, Romance, 1987)
27		Stealing Beauty (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 1996)
27		Passion of Mind (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2000)
27		Waking the Dead (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2000)
27		Random Hearts (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 1999)
27		Snow Falling on Cedars (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 1999)
27		Last Embrace (Mystery, Romance, Thriller, 1979)
27		Killing Me Softly (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2002)
27		Vanilla Sky (Fantasy, Mystery, Romance, 2001)
27		Auggie Rose (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2000)
27		The Claim (Drama, Romance, Western, 2000)
27		Dust (Drama, Romance, Western, 2001)
27		All the Pretty Horses (Drama, Romance, Western, 2000)
27		Urban Legends: Final Cut (Horror, Mystery, Romance, 2000)
27		Cherry Falls (Horror, Mystery, Romance, 2000)
27		Possession (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2002)
27		Immortality (Crime, Mystery, Romance, 1998)
27		Cypher (Mystery, Romance, Sci-Fi, 2002)
27		The Quiet American (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2002)
27		Bad Girls (Romance, Western, 1994)
27		China Moon (Crime, Mystery, Romance, 1994)
27		Head Over Heels (Comedy, Mystery, Romance, 2001)
27		Color of Night (Mystery, Romance, Thriller, 1994)
27		The Constant Gardener (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2005)
27		Swept from the Sea (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 1997)
27		Dead Man's Curve (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 1998)
27		Enigma (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2001)
27		Boys (Mystery, Drama, Romance, 1996)
27		3 A.M. (Crime, Mystery, Romance, 2001)
27		Flesh and Bone (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 1993)
27		Last Train from Gun Hill (Romance, Western, 1959)
27		Possession (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2008)
27		Wake of the Red Witch (Action, Adventure, Romance, 1948)
27		David's Birthday (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2009)
27		Chloe (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2009)
27		Ondine (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2009)
27		I Shot Jesse James (Drama, History, Romance, 1949)
27		Passengers (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2008)
27		Chaotic Ana (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2007)
27		To Catch a Thief (Crime, Mystery, Romance, 1955)
27		Comes a Horseman (Drama, Western, Romance, 1978)
27		The Fighting Kentuckian (Adventure, Romance, War, 1949)
27		A Summer in Genoa (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2008)
27		Kaboom (Comedy, Mystery, Romance, 2010)
27		Shanghai (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2010)
27		Haunt (Horror, Mystery, Romance, 2014)
27		Boom Town (Adventure, Drama, Romance, 1940)
27		Transcendence (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2014)
27		The Loft (Mystery, Romance, Thriller, 2014)
27		Paper Towns (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2015)
27		Frequencies (Mystery, Romance, Sci-Fi, 2013)
27		Night Train to Lisbon (Mystery, Romance, Thriller, 2013)
27		Crime d'amour (Crime, Mystery, Romance, 2010)
27		Mistérios de Lisboa (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2010)
27		Dead Awake (Fantasy, Mystery, Romance, 2010)
27		The Words (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2012)
27		Oklahoma! (Musical, Romance, Western, 1955)
27		Quid Pro Quo (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2008)
27		The Misfits (Drama, Romance, Western, 1961)
27		Skin Game (Comedy, Romance, Western, 1971)
27		Cimarron (Drama, Romance, Western, 1960)
27		The Rare Breed (Drama, Romance, Western, 1966)
27		They Might Be Giants (Mystery, Comedy, Romance, 1971)
27		Twice-Told Tales (Horror, Mystery, Romance, 1963)
27		Frogs (Horror, Mystery, Romance, 1972)
27		The Moon-Spinners (Family, Mystery, Romance, 1964)
27		Tribute to a Bad Man (Drama, Romance, Western, 1956)
27		The Unforgiven (Drama, Romance, Western, 1960)
27		Keep Your Distance (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2005)
27		Jubal (Drama, Romance, Western, 1956)
27		Cat Ballou (Comedy, Romance, Western, 1965)
27		The Big Sleep (Crime, Mystery, Romance, 1978)
27		Hallam Foe (Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2007)
27		Love Me Tender (Drama, Romance, Western, 1956)
27		Forty Guns (Romance, Western, 1957)
27		The Book of Revelation (Mystery, Romance, Thriller, 2006)
27		The Rainmaker (Romance, Western, 1956)
27		Support Your Local Gunfighter (Comedy, Romance, Western, 1971)
26		Tombstone (Action, Biography, Drama, Romance, 1993)
26		The Quiet Man (Comedy, Drama, Romance, 1952)
25		The Jewel of the Nile (Action, Adventure, Comedy, Romance, 1985)
25		Hate Crime (Crime, Drama, Mystery, Romance, 2005)
25		Gotcha! (Action, Comedy, Mystery, Romance, 1985)
25		Ride Along (Action, Comedy, Crime, Romance, 2014)
25		Rebecca (Drama, Film-Noir, Mystery, Romance, 1940)
25		Fallen Angel (Crime, Film-Noir, Mystery, Romance, 1945)
25		The Ghost and Mrs. Muir (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, Romance, 1947)
25		Hondo (Drama, Romance, War, 1953)
25		Great Expectations (Adventure, Drama, Mystery, Romance, 1946)
25		The Thin Man Goes Home (Comedy, Crime, Mystery, Romance, 1945)
25		The Uninvited (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, Romance, 1944)
25		Bandolero! (Action, Crime, Drama, Romance, 1968)
25		Lady of Burlesque (Comedy, Music, Mystery, Romance, 1943)
24		Kidulthood (Crime, Drama, Romance, 2006)
24		Viva Maria! (Adventure, Comedy, Romance, 1965)
24		Flying Tigers (Action, Drama, War, Romance, 1942)
24		Secret Beyond the Door... (Drama, Film-Noir, Mystery, Romance, 1947)
24		The Jungle Book (Adventure, Family, Romance, 1994)
24		Reap the Wild Wind (Action, Adventure, Drama, Romance, 1942)
24		Little Caesar (Crime, Drama, Romance, 1931)
24		Donovan's Reef (Adventure, Comedy, Romance, 1963)
24		The Life and Times of Judge Roy Bean (Comedy, Drama, Romance, 1972)
24		Jet Pilot (Action, Drama, Romance, 1957)
24		Bus Stop (Comedy, Drama, Romance, 1956)

Notes: Movies similar to Tall in the Saddle, Movies like Tall in the Saddle, Mystery, Western, Romance, Edwin L. Marin, John Wayne, Ella Raines, Ward Bond, George 'Gabby' Hayes, Films, Video, Movie Similarities