73		Maniac Cop (Action, Crime, Horror, 1988)
72		The Final Terror (Horror, 1983)
69		The Town That Dreaded Sundown (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1976)
65		Halloween (Horror, Thriller, 1978)
65		Donkey Punch (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2008)
62		Rivelazioni di un maniaco sessuale al capo della squadra mobile (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1972)
62		Pathology (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 2008)
61		Lady Stay Dead (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1981)
60		The Bad Seed (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1956)
58		Road Games (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1981)
57		Bone Tomahawk (Adventure, Drama, Horror, 2015)
55		7 Days (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2010)
54		The Silent Scream (Horror, Thriller, 1979)
54		Manhunter (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1986)
54		When a Stranger Calls (Horror, Thriller, 2006)
52		The Killing Floor (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 2007)
52		Crimson Peak (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2015)
52		Grace (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2009)
52		Lisa (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1989)
51		Massacre at Central High (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1976)
51		The Stepfather (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1987)
51		Ghost Story (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1981)
50		American Mary (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2012)
50		The Devil's Muse (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2007)
49		I Saw What You Did (Horror, Thriller, 1965)
49		You'll Like My Mother (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1972)
49		Urban Legends: Final Cut (Horror, Mystery, Romance, 2000)
48		Friday the 13th Part 2 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1981)
48		Pieces (Horror, Mystery, 1982)
48		Wolfen (Horror, Thriller, 1981)
47		Red White & Blue (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2010)
47		Discopathe (Crime, Fantasy, Horror, 2013)
47		Rocktober Blood (Horror, Music, 1984)
47		Girls Against Boys (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2012)
47		Dominion: Prequel to the Exorcist (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2005)
47		Lady in a Cage (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1964)
47		The Watcher (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 2000)
47		The Lords of Salem (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2012)
47		Coma (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1978)
46		Sisters (Horror, Thriller, 1972)
46		Near Dark (Action, Crime, Drama, Horror, 1987)
46		Martin (Drama, Horror, 1977)
46		April Fool's Day (Horror, Mystery, 1986)
45		Strange Confession (Crime, Horror, Drama, 1945)
45		Scream for Help (Horror, Mystery, Crime, 1984)
45		The Evictors (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1979)
45		Hellraiser (Fantasy, Horror, 1987)
45		Blood Rage (Horror, 1987)
44		Amusement (Horror, Thriller, 2008)
44		Nightmare (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1981)
44		Two Evil Eyes (Horror, 1990)
44		Babysitter Wanted (Horror, Thriller, 2008)
44		The Possession of Joel Delaney (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1972)
44		Creep (Horror, Thriller, 2014)
44		City in Panic (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 1986)
44		My Little Eye (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2002)
44		In the Blood (Horror, Thriller, 2006)
44		Old 37 (Horror, 2015)
44		Dværgen (Adult, Crime, Horror, 1973)
43		Act of Vengeance (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1974)
43		Night Warning (Horror, 1982)
43		Nosferatu the Vampyre (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1979)
43		Sicilian Vampire (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2015)
43		Ilsa: She Wolf of the SS (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1975)
43		Amityville II: The Possession (Horror, 1982)
43		Vampire at Midnight (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1988)
43		The Confessional (Horror, 1976)
43		Monkey Shines (Drama, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1988)
43		Nightmare Honeymoon (Crime, Horror, Drama, 1974)
43		Cat People (Fantasy, Horror, Thriller, 1982)
42		What the Peeper Saw (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1972)
42		The Killing Kind (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1973)
42		The Last House on the Left (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1972)
42		Endless Night (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1972)
42		Diabolique (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1955)
42		Screamtime (Fantasy, Horror, 1983)
42		Haunted (Drama, Horror, 1995)
42		The Mafu Cage (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1978)
42		Beyond Dream's Door (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1989)
42		The Uninvited (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2009)
42		The Unborn (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2009)
42		Mindhunters (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 2004)
42		The Shallows (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2016)
42		Children of the Corn (Horror, Thriller, 1984)
42		She-Wolf of London (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1946)
42		The Stranger (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2014)
42		Evilenko (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 2004)
42		Clown (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2014)
42		The Night Stalker (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1986)
41		Hush...Hush, Sweet Charlotte (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1964)
41		Scream and Scream Again (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1970)
41		Don't Turn Out the Light (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1987)
41		Hunter's Blood (Adventure, Horror, Thriller, 1986)
41		Stripped to Kill (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1987)
41		The Believers (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1987)
41		Prison (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1987)
41		Goodbye Gemini (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1970)
41		White Dog (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1982)
40		Acolytes (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2008)
40		Surveillance (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2008)
40		Resurrection (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1999)
40		Senseless (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2008)
40		Perfect Blue (Animation, Horror, Music, 1997)
40		iMurders (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2008)
40		Grimm Love (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2006)
40		The Road (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2011)
40		The Lodger (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2009)
40		The Coverup (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2008)
40		Le pharmacien de garde (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2003)
40		The Penalty (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1920)
40		Whisper (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2007)
40		Bless the Child (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2000)
40		The Killing Gene (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2007)
40		The Black Dahlia Haunting (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2012)
40		Ricky 6 (Biography, Crime, Drama, Horror, 2000)
40		Funny Games (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2007)
40		The Bells (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1926)
40		The Tall Man (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2012)
40		The Spreading Ground (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2000)
40		The Girl Next Door (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2007)
40		Kalifornia (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1993)
40		StageFright (Horror, 1987)
40		Daughter of Darkness (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1948)
40		The Hand (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1960)
40		Choose (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2011)
40		The Flesh and the Fiends (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1960)
40		The Zodiac (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2005)
40		Dead Man's Eyes (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1944)
40		Cheap (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2005)
40		The Monster and the Girl (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1941)
40		Wicked City (Animation, Fantasy, Horror, 1987)
40		Nine Dead (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2010)
40		Megan Is Missing (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2011)
40		Blood Harvest (Horror, 1987)
40		The Brain (Crime, Horror, Drama, 1962)
40		Madhouse (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1974)
40		The Lost (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2006)
39		House with 100 Eyes (Horror, 2013)
39		White Slave (Adventure, Drama, Horror, 1985)
39		Drive-In Horrorshow (Horror, 2009)
39		Happy Hell Night (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1992)
39		Nightmare City (Action, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1980)
39		The Amityville Horror (Horror, 1979)
39		Scream (Horror, Mystery, 1996)
39		Nekromantik 2 (Horror, 1991)
39		The Signal (Horror, Sci-Fi, Thriller, 2007)
39		The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (Horror, 2003)
39		Afflicted (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
39		Heartstopper (Horror, Thriller, 2006)
38		Taste the Blood of Dracula (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1970)
38		Dead of Winter (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1987)
38		The Living Dead Girl (Horror, 1982)
38		Interview with the Vampire: The Vampire Chronicles (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1994)
38		The Night Digger (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1971)
38		Humongous (Horror, Romance, 1982)
38		House of Dark Shadows (Drama, Horror, Romance, 1970)
37		I Am Legend (Drama, Horror, Sci-Fi, 2007)
37		The Wolfman (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2010)
37		Sensored (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2009)
37		Les nuits rouges du bourreau de jade (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 2010)
37		Stake Land (Drama, Horror, Sci-Fi, 2010)
37		Wolf (Drama, Horror, Romance, 1994)
37		Romasanta (Drama, Horror, 2004)
37		Frightmare (Horror, 1983)
37		La casa con la scala nel buio (Horror, Mystery, 1983)
37		The Last Exorcism (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2010)
37		Condemned to Live (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1935)
37		The Bleeding House (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2011)
37		Martyrs (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2015)
37		Night Shadows (Horror, Sci-Fi, Thriller, 1984)
37		Among Dead Men (Action, Crime, Horror, 2008)
37		The Curse of the Cat People (Drama, Horror, 1944)
37		Green Room (Crime, Horror, Music, 2015)
37		Eroddity(s) (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2014)
37		Vampire (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2011)
37		The Vampire Bat (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1933)
37		Puffball: The Devil's Eyeball (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2007)
37		Head Case (Drama, Horror, 2007)
37		Goddess of Love (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2015)
37		Inn of the Damned (Horror, Western, Thriller, 1975)
37		The Texas Chain Saw Massacre (Horror, Thriller, 1974)
37		Chrysalis (Drama, Horror, Sci-Fi, 2014)
37		Murders in the Rue Morgue (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1932)
37		Nobody (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 2007)
37		The Mothman Prophecies (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2002)
37		Summer Scars (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2007)
37		Feed (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 2005)
36		The Crazies (Action, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1973)
36		A Stranger Is Watching (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 1982)
36		The Territory (Drama, Horror, 1981)
35		Willard (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1971)
35		Tropical Inferno (Action, Crime, Drama, Horror, 1978)
35		The Gate (Fantasy, Horror, 1987)
35		And Soon the Darkness (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1970)
35		The Countess (Biography, Drama, History, Horror, 2009)
35		Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers (Horror, Thriller, 1988)
35		Hands of the Ripper (Horror, 1971)
35		Child's Play (Horror, 1988)
34		Nightlight (Horror, Thriller, 2015)
34		Salvage (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
34		Body Parts (Horror, Thriller, 1991)
34		Tales from the Crypt: Demon Knight (Action, Fantasy, Horror, 1995)
34		Horrors of the Black Museum (Horror, 1959)
34		388 Arletta Avenue (Horror, Thriller, 2011)
34		Scream of Fear (Horror, Thriller, 1961)
34		Midnight Son (Horror, 2011)
34		Exists (Action, Adventure, Horror, 2014)
34		Most Likely to Die (Horror, 2015)
34		Jeepers Creepers (Horror, Mystery, 2001)
34		Darkness (Horror, 2002)
34		Truth About Demons (Horror, Thriller, Fantasy, 2000)
34		Supernova (Horror, Sci-Fi, Thriller, 2000)
34		Lighthouse (Horror, Thriller, 1999)
34		The Ghouls (Horror, 2003)
34		Open Grave (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
34		Mockingbird (Horror, Thriller, 2014)
34		The Legend of Boggy Creek (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1972)
34		House of Wax (Horror, 2005)
34		The Shining (Drama, Horror, 1980)
34		The Wizard of Gore (Horror, Mystery, 2007)

Notes: Movies similar to When a Stranger Calls, Movies like When a Stranger Calls, Crime, Drama, Horror, Fred Walton, Carol Kane, Charles Durning, Rutanya Alda, Carmen Argenziano, Films, Video, Movie Similarities