99		Dead & Buried (Horror, Mystery, 1981)
99		My Bloody Valentine (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1981)
99		La casa con la scala nel buio (Horror, Mystery, 1983)
99		The Poughkeepsie Tapes (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2007)
99		Friday the 13th (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1980)
99		Toolbox Murders (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
99		The Last House on the Left (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 2009)
98		The House on Sorority Row (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1983)
98		The Burning (Horror, 1981)
95		StageFright (Horror, 1987)
93		Curtains (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1983)
92		Wolf Creek 2 (Action, Horror, Thriller, 2013)
92		Amsterdamned (Action, Horror, Thriller, 1988)
92		The Loved Ones (Horror, Thriller, 2009)
91		X-Ray (Horror, Thriller, 1981)
89		Friday the 13th Part VII: The New Blood (Horror, 1988)
88		Girls Nite Out (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1982)
86		Just Before Dawn (Horror, Thriller, 1981)
84		Silent Madness (Horror, Thriller, 1984)
84		Sweet Kill (Horror, Thriller, 1972)
83		Tenebre (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1982)
82		31 (Horror, Thriller, 2016)
79		Maniac Cop (Action, Crime, Horror, 1988)
77		The Rage: Carrie 2 (Horror, Sci-Fi, Thriller, 1999)
77		The Signal (Horror, Sci-Fi, Thriller, 2007)
77		Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers (Horror, Thriller, 1995)
77		Sleepaway Camp (Horror, 1983)
77		Intruder (Horror, Thriller, 1989)
77		Strangeland (Horror, Thriller, 1998)
76		Hell Night (Horror, Thriller, 1981)
75		The Town That Dreaded Sundown (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
75		Sleepless (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2001)
73		Jason Lives: Friday the 13th Part VI (Horror, Thriller, 1986)
71		Madman (Horror, Thriller, 1981)
71		He Knows You're Alone (Horror, Thriller, 1980)
70		Blood Rage (Horror, 1987)
70		Sweet 16 (Horror, Thriller, 1983)
69		The Gift (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2000)
68		City in Panic (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 1986)
68		Open House (Horror, Thriller, 1987)
68		Night Watch (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1973)
67		Dark Corners (Horror, Romance, Thriller, 2006)
67		The Purge (Horror, Sci-Fi, Thriller, 2013)
66		New Year's Evil (Horror, Thriller, 1980)
65		Anguish (Horror, 1987)
65		The Skeleton Key (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2005)
65		Dead End (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2003)
65		The Boy (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2016)
64		Invitation Only (Horror, Romance, 2009)
63		Crawlspace (Horror, Thriller, 1986)
62		The Mephisto Waltz (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1971)
62		Reeker (Horror, Mystery, 2005)
62		Deadly Intruder (Horror, Thriller, 1988)
62		Tamara (Horror, Fantasy, Thriller, 2005)
62		Halloween 5 (Horror, Thriller, 1989)
62		Lady in a Cage (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1964)
62		Reminiscence: The Beginning (Horror, Romance, Thriller, 2014)
61		The Reincarnation of Peter Proud (Horror, Mystery, 1975)
61		The Last House on the Left (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1972)
61		Forced Entry (Horror, Thriller, 1975)
60		Devil (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
60		The Incubus (Horror, Thriller, 1982)
59		The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (Horror, 2003)
59		The Collector (Horror, 2009)
59		The Girl Next Door (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2007)
57		The Millennium Bug (Horror, Sci-Fi, Thriller, 2011)
57		Silent Rage (Action, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1982)
57		Psycho (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1960)
57		Mortuary (Horror, 1983)
57		Ripper (Horror, Thriller, 2001)
56		And Soon the Darkness (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1970)
56		Graduation Day (Horror, Mystery, 1981)
55		Nightmare (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1964)
55		From Hell (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2001)
54		High Tension (Horror, 2003)
54		Resurrection (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1999)
54		Halloween (Horror, 2007)
54		Combat Shock (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1984)
53		The Love Butcher (Horror, 1975)
52		ATM (Horror, Thriller, 2012)
52		Seven Days to Live (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2000)
52		The Cabin in the Woods (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2012)
50		Truth or Dare?: A Critical Madness (Horror, 1986)
50		The Candy Snatchers (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 1973)
50		Night Monster (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1942)
50		Cut! (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
49		The Unnamable (Horror, 1988)
49		Blind Date (Horror, Thriller, 1984)
49		Candyman (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1992)
48		Murder by Phone (Horror, Thriller, Mystery, 1982)
47		The Pool (Horror, Thriller, 2001)
47		Repentance (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2013)
47		Close Your Eyes (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 2002)
47		Screamtime (Fantasy, Horror, 1983)
47		Lisa (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1989)
47		Cherry Tree Lane (Horror, Thriller, 2010)
46		They Don't Cut the Grass Anymore (Horror, 1985)
46		The Long Island Cannibal Massacre (Horror, Thriller, 1980)
45		Murder in the Dark (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
45		Mask of Murder (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1988)
45		The Comeback (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1978)
45		Impulse (Horror, Thriller, 1974)
45		Long Weekend (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1978)
44		The Spiral Staircase (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1975)
44		Road Games (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1981)
44		The Amityville Horror (Horror, 1979)
44		Happy Birthday to Me (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1981)
44		Burnt Offerings (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1976)
44		Don't Answer the Phone! (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1980)
44		Black Water (Action, Drama, Horror, 2007)
44		Friday the 13th Part 2 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1981)
44		A Reflection of Fear (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1972)
44		Alice Sweet Alice (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1976)
44		The Survivor (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1981)
44		The Prowler (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1981)
43		Island of Blood (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1982)
43		Wicked, Wicked (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1973)
43		Black Christmas (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1974)
43		Klynham Summer (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1982)
43		Seven Dead in the Cat's Eye (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1973)
43		Next of Kin (Horror, Thriller, Mystery, 1982)
42		The Initiation (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1984)
42		Oculus (Horror, Mystery, 2013)
42		Gone (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2006)
42		Poltergeist (Horror, Thriller, 2015)
42		The Monitor (Horror, Thriller, 2011)
42		Bluebeard (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 1944)
42		Friday the 13th: A New Beginning (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1985)
42		The Zodiac Killer (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1971)
42		Silent Night, Bloody Night (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1972)
42		Killer's Delight (Thriller, Horror, 1978)
42		Hush (Horror, Thriller, 2008)
42		They Live (Horror, Sci-Fi, Thriller, 1988)
42		The Silent Scream (Horror, Thriller, 1979)
41		Saw (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
41		Nomads (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1986)
41		Morirai a mezzanotte (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1986)
41		The Stepford Wives (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 1975)
41		The House That Screamed (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1970)
41		Willard (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1971)
41		The Conjuring 2 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2016)
41		Angel Heart (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1987)
41		Witchboard (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1986)
41		The Hound of the Baskervilles (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1939)
41		Psycho III (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1986)
40		They (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2002)
40		Nine Miles Down (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
40		The Last Winter (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
40		Sinister 2 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2015)
40		Supernatural (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1933)
40		Orphan (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
40		The Conjuring (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
40		Don't Hang Up (Horror, Thriller, 1974)
40		Wrath of the Crows (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
40		Willow Creek (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
40		Evidence (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
40		Bikini Island (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1991)
40		Whispers (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1990)
40		Left for Dead (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2007)
40		June 9 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
40		Dolls (Fantasy, Horror, 1987)
40		The Strangers (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
40		Open Grave (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
40		The Black Water Vampire (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
40		Ghosthouse (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1988)
40		Night of Terror (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1933)
40		Dark Tower (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1989)
40		100 Feet (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
40		Room 6 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
40		Blackout (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
40		Under Surveillance (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
40		Dark Signal (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2016)
40		The Tunnel (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2011)
40		The Return (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
40		I'll Bury You Tomorrow (Horror, Thriller, Mystery, 2002)
40		Honeymoon (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
40		My Little Eye (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2002)
40		Mystery of the Wax Museum (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1933)
40		Afflicted (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
40		The Woods (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
40		Shutter (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
40		Lost Place (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
40		Hangman's Curse (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2003)
40		The Shortcut (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
40		Fingerprints (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
40		The Den (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
40		Horror Island (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1941)
40		Evil Things (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
40		Case 39 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
40		Deliver Us from Evil (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
40		Breathing Room (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
40		Inner Demons (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
40		The Night Has Eyes (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1942)
40		The Abandoned (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
40		The Darkroom (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
40		Autopsy (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
40		Turistas (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
40		Penny Dreadful (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
40		Below (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2002)
40		The Oregonian (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2011)
40		Octane (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2003)
40		The Canal (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
40		Visions (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2015)
40		The Dead Outside (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
40		From Within (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
40		The Collingswood Story (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2002)
40		Salvage (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
40		Jennifer's Shadow (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
40		The Living Ghost (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1942)
40		The Inn (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
40		Mommy's Day (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1997)
40		Bigfoot: The Lost Coast Tapes (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2012)
40		The Grudge (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
40		Breaking Dawn (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
40		Berserk (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1967)
40		The Messengers (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2007)
40		The Blood Lands (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
40		Valentine (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2001)
40		Severed Footage (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2012)
40		Les morsures de l'aube (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2001)
40		The Toybox (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2005)
40		I Can See You (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
40		Lemon Tree Passage (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2015)
40		Lord of Illusions (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1995)
40		The City of the Dead (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1960)
40		Reaper (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2000)
40		Homicidal (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1961)
40		11-11-11 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2011)
40		The Children (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
40		Mommy (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1995)
40		The Pact (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2012)
40		Barricade (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2012)
40		Atrocious (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
40		I Know What You Did Last Summer (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1997)
40		Visions (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
40		Imago mortis (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
40		The Night Walker (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1964)
40		The Thing on the Doorstep (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
40		The Taking of Deborah Logan (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
40		Hollow (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2011)
40		House on Haunted Hill (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1999)
40		Last Shift (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
40		My Soul to Take (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
40		Kolobos (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1999)
40		The 4th Floor (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1999)
40		Stir of Echoes (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1999)
40		i-Lived (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2015)
40		Psycho (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1998)
40		The Mysterious Doctor (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1943)
40		Dark Awakening (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
40		Eternal (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
40		The Eighteenth Angel (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1997)
40		Blood Fiend (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1967)
40		The Gruesome Twosome (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1967)
40		Resolution (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2012)
40		Exorcist: The Beginning (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
40		Psycho-Circus (Mystery, Thriller, Horror, 1966)
40		Urban Legend (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1998)
40		Vanishing on 7th Street (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
40		Creep (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
40		The St. Francisville Experiment (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2000)
40		The Shadow of the Cat (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1961)
40		Srpski film (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
40		In Fear (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
40		Farm House (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
40		Wendigo (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2001)
40		6 Souls (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
40		Killer Me (Mystery, Thriller, Horror, 2001)
40		An American Haunting (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2005)
40		Haunter (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
40		Cybernatural (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
40		Bela Kiss: Prologue (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
40		Trauma (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1993)
40		Come Back to Me (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
40		Woetoli (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
40		Deadly Revisions (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
40		House Hunting (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
40		Darkness Falls (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2003)
40		The Reeds (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
40		The Spiral Staircase (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1945)
40		The Dark Half (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1993)
40		Almost Dead (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1994)
40		The Grudge 3 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
40		Psych:9 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
40		A Nightmare on Elm Street (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
40		Evil Angel (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
40		Happy Hell Night (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1992)
40		The Jailhouse (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
40		Beneath (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2007)
40		Pod (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2015)
40		Rage: Midsummer's Eve (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2015)
40		The Bat (Horror, Thriller, Mystery, 1959)
40		Exeter (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2015)
40		The Card Player (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
40		Gothika (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2003)
40		The Forest (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2016)
40		The Mad Magician (Horror, Thriller, Mystery, 1954)
40		Amber Alert (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2012)
40		Eyes of the Beholder (Thriller, Horror, Mystery, 1992)
40		Encounter with the Unknown (Horror, Mystery, 1973)
40		The Dark (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2005)
40		Chasing Sleep (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2000)
40		They Wait (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2007)
40		Madison County (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2011)

Notes: Movies similar to The Toolbox Murders, Movies like The Toolbox Murders, Horror, Mystery, Thriller, Dennis Donnelly, Cameron Mitchell, Pamelyn Ferdin, Wesley Eure, Nicolas Beauvy, Films, Video, Movie Similarities