65		Sinister (Horror, Mystery, 2012)
60		Phenomena (Horror, Mystery, 1985)
60		Saw IV (Horror, Mystery, 2007)
60		Night School (Horror, Mystery, 1981)
57		The Reincarnation of Peter Proud (Horror, Mystery, 1975)
55		Saw II (Horror, Mystery, 2005)
55		Jeepers Creepers (Horror, Mystery, 2001)
55		Scream 4 (Horror, Mystery, 2011)
55		I Still Know What You Did Last Summer (Horror, Mystery, 1998)
55		Retribution (Horror, Mystery, 1987)
55		Inferno (Horror, Mystery, 1980)
55		Dead & Buried (Horror, Mystery, 1981)
55		Pieces (Horror, Mystery, 1982)
55		Oculus (Horror, Mystery, 2013)
55		The Last Broadcast (Horror, Mystery, 1998)
55		Scream (Horror, Mystery, 1996)
55		The VVitch: A New-England Folktale (Horror, Mystery, 2015)
55		Annabelle (Horror, Mystery, 2014)
53		Dark Intruder (Horror, Mystery, 1965)
52		Trauma (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1993)
51		The Zodiac Killer (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1971)
51		Rosemary's Baby (Drama, Horror, 1968)
50		The Ring (Horror, Mystery, 2002)
50		The Strange Case of Doctor Rx (Horror, Mystery, 1942)
50		It Follows (Horror, Mystery, 2014)
50		Witchboard 2 (Horror, Mystery, 1993)
50		Saw V (Horror, Mystery, 2008)
50		The Beast with Five Fingers (Horror, Mystery, 1946)
50		Spellcaster (Horror, Mystery, 1988)
49		The Wicker Man (Horror, Mystery, 1973)
49		Something Weird (Fantasy, Horror, 1967)
48		Curse of the Demon (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 1957)
48		The Satanic Rites of Dracula (Horror, 1973)
48		The Black Torment (Horror, Mystery, 1964)
47		Close Your Eyes (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 2002)
47		My Soul to Take (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
47		Lady in White (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 1988)
47		Toolbox Murders (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
47		Double Vision (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2002)
47		The Night Flier (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 1997)
47		The Spiral Staircase (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1945)
47		Cherry Falls (Horror, Mystery, Romance, 2000)
47		She-Wolf of London (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1946)
47		Videodrome (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 1983)
47		Psycho III (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1986)
47		Happy Birthday to Me (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1981)
47		Sinister 2 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2015)
47		The Devil's Men (Horror, 1976)
46		Suspiria (Horror, Mystery, 1977)
46		Terror (Horror, 1978)
46		Ruby (Drama, Horror, 1977)
46		Berserk (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1967)
45		Scream 3 (Horror, Mystery, 2000)
45		Scream 2 (Horror, Mystery, 1997)
45		Murder by the Clock (Horror, Mystery, 1931)
45		Pillow of Death (Mystery, Horror, 1945)
45		La casa con la scala nel buio (Horror, Mystery, 1983)
45		The Pit (Horror, Mystery, 1981)
45		Mark of the Vampire (Horror, Mystery, 1935)
45		The Sender (Horror, Thriller, 1982)
45		Curse of Chucky (Horror, Thriller, 2013)
45		Candyman: Farewell to the Flesh (Horror, 1995)
45		3 Extremes II (Horror, Mystery, 2002)
45		Woman Who Came Back (Horror, Mystery, 1945)
45		Chasing the Devil (Horror, 2014)
45		Spirits of the Dead (Horror, Mystery, 1968)
45		Deadwood Park (Horror, Mystery, 2007)
44		The First Power (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 1990)
44		Beware My Brethren (Horror, 1972)
44		Evil Come Evil Go (Horror, 1972)
44		Twin Peaks: The Missing Pieces (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2014)
44		House of Dark Shadows (Drama, Horror, Romance, 1970)
44		Sweet Kill (Horror, Thriller, 1972)
44		Warlock (Action, Fantasy, Horror, 1989)
44		The Brotherhood of Satan (Horror, 1971)
43		Two on a Guillotine (Mystery, Horror, 1965)
43		Day of the Nightmare (Horror, Mystery, 1965)
43		The Beast Must Die (Horror, Mystery, 1974)
43		The Legend of the 7 Golden Vampires (Horror, 1974)
43		Three on a Meathook (Horror, 1973)
43		Encounter with the Unknown (Horror, Mystery, 1973)
43		Terror in the Wax Museum (Horror, Mystery, 1973)
43		The Conjuring 2 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2016)
43		The House on Skull Mountain (Horror, Mystery, 1974)
42		Crawlspace (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 2012)
42		Ten (Adventure, Horror, Mystery, 2014)
42		Night Monster (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1942)
42		Eye See You (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 2002)
42		From Hell (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2001)
42		Reaper (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2000)
42		Valentine (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2001)
42		The Return of Doctor X (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 1939)
42		Goddess of Love (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2015)
42		Schizoid (Action, Horror, Mystery, 1980)
42		The Card Player (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
42		Friday the 13th Part 2 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1981)
42		The Call of Cthulhu (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
42		Cry_Wolf (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
42		11-11-11 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2011)
42		Red Lights (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2012)
42		The Collingswood Story (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2002)
42		Burn, Witch, Burn (Horror, 1962)
42		The Haunted Strangler (Crime, Mystery, Horror, 1958)
42		Morirai a mezzanotte (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1986)
42		Blood Feast (Horror, 1963)
42		The Amityville Horror (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
42		The Midnight Meat Train (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2008)
41		The Medusa Touch (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1978)
41		Haunts (Horror, 1977)
41		Jennifer (Horror, 1978)
41		Child's Play (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1972)
41		God Told Me To (Crime, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1976)
41		A Reflection of Fear (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1972)
40		The Devil Rides Out (Horror, 1968)
40		Truth or Die (Horror, Mystery, 2012)
40		I Drink Your Blood (Horror, 1970)
40		Night Watch (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1973)
40		Black Christmas (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1974)
40		StageFright (Horror, 1987)
40		Reeker (Horror, Mystery, 2005)
40		The Marsh (Horror, Thriller, 2006)
40		Session 9 (Horror, Mystery, 2001)
40		Saw 3D: The Final Chapter (Horror, Mystery, 2010)
40		Devil's Due (Horror, Mystery, 2014)
40		Ricky 6 (Biography, Crime, Drama, Horror, 2000)
40		Saw VI (Horror, Mystery, 2009)
40		The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning (Horror, 2006)
40		The Eye (Horror, Mystery, 2008)
40		Mirrors (Horror, Mystery, 2008)
40		Solstice (Horror, Mystery, 2008)
40		Mother of Tears (Horror, 2007)
40		The Wizard of Gore (Horror, Mystery, 2007)
40		Don't Blink (Horror, Mystery, 2014)
40		Creep (Horror, Mystery, 1995)
40		Silent Madness (Horror, Thriller, 1984)
40		The Cat and the Canary (Horror, Mystery, 1927)
40		Soulmate (Horror, Mystery, 2013)
40		Graduation Day (Horror, Mystery, 1981)
40		To All a Goodnight (Horror, Mystery, 1980)
40		Altar (Horror, Mystery, 2014)
40		April Fool's Day (Horror, Mystery, 1986)
40		Final Prayer (Horror, Mystery, 2013)
40		The Addiction (Horror, 1995)
40		Blood Rage (Horror, 1987)
40		Bloody New Year (Horror, Mystery, 1987)
40		Sorority Row (Horror, Mystery, 2009)
40		Screams of a Winter Night (Horror, Mystery, 1979)
40		Rocktober Blood (Horror, Music, 1984)
40		The Hound of the Baskervilles (Horror, Mystery, 1959)
40		The Ninth Guest (Horror, Mystery, 1934)
40		The Four Skulls of Jonathan Drake (Horror, Mystery, 1959)
39		The Echo Game (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2009)
39		Daughters of Darkness (Horror, 1971)
39		Willard (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1971)
39		The Plague of the Zombies (Fantasy, Horror, 1966)
39		Blood Thirst (Horror, 1971)
39		Hands of the Ripper (Horror, 1971)
38		Vampyres (Horror, 1974)
38		Saw (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
38		The Comeback (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1978)
38		The Legend of Hell House (Horror, 1973)
38		Doctor Death: Seeker of Souls (Horror, 1973)
38		Axe (Horror, 1974)
38		Homicidal (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1961)
38		Enter the Devil (Horror, 1974)
38		Enter the Devil (Horror, Thriller, Western, 1972)
38		The Texas Chain Saw Massacre (Horror, Thriller, 1974)
38		It's Alive (Horror, 1974)
38		From Beyond the Grave (Fantasy, Horror, 1974)
37		Mystery of Edwin Drood (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1935)
37		Deranged: Confessions of a Necrophile (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1974)
37		Sleepy Hollow (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 1999)
37		The St. Francisville Experiment (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2000)
37		Insensibles (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2012)
37		The Vampire Bat (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1933)
37		The Canal (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
37		As Above, So Below (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2014)
37		Malevolence (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 2003)
37		Dream No Evil (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1970)
37		The Den (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
37		Chasing Sleep (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2000)
37		Sleepless (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2001)
37		Open Grave (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
37		Afflicted (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
37		The Watcher (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 2000)
37		Disturbing Behavior (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 1998)
37		The Bat (Horror, Thriller, Mystery, 1959)
37		Jack the Ripper (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1959)
37		Tenebre (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1982)
37		Klynham Summer (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1982)
37		The Prowler (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1981)
37		Road Games (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1981)
37		Strange Behavior (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 1981)
37		The Poughkeepsie Tapes (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2007)
37		The House on Sorority Row (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1983)
37		Horror Island (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1941)
37		Angel Heart (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1987)
37		Friday the 13th: A New Beginning (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1985)
37		The Strangers (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
37		Strange Invaders (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 1983)
37		Blackout (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
37		The Children (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
37		The Darkroom (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
37		Who Can Kill a Child? (Fantasy, Horror, 1976)
37		Mommy's Day (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1997)
37		The Crime of Doctor Crespi (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1935)
37		Psychic Killer (Thriller, Horror, 1975)
37		The Rite (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2011)
37		Urban Legend (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1998)
37		The Stranger (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2014)
37		Crash! (Horror, 1976)
37		Island of Death (Horror, 1976)
37		New Nightmare (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 1994)
37		Slaughter of the Innocents (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1993)
37		Cyrus (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 2010)
37		In the Mouth of Madness (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 1994)
37		Deadly Sins (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1995)
37		The Nature of the Beast (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1995)
37		Gui si (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2006)
37		The Tunnel (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2011)
37		Dead Men Walk (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1943)

Notes: Movies similar to The Witchmaker, Movies like The Witchmaker, Horror, Mystery, William O. Brown, Anthony Eisley, Thordis Brandt, Alvy Moore, John Lodge, Films, Video, Movie Similarities