77		Strait-Jacket (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1964)
75		The Unknown (Drama, Horror, Romance, 1927)
70		The Monster and the Girl (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1941)
62		The Raven (Crime, Horror, 1935)
60		The Girl Next Door (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2007)
60		Kalifornia (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1993)
60		7 Days (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2010)
60		Rivelazioni di un maniaco sessuale al capo della squadra mobile (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1972)
56		Hush...Hush, Sweet Charlotte (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1964)
55		Needful Things (Crime, Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1993)
55		Nightmare (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1981)
53		Sicilian Vampire (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2015)
52		Devoured (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2012)
52		Phantom of the Opera (Drama, Horror, Music, 1943)
52		Sugar Hill (Action, Crime, Horror, 1974)
52		Olga's Girls (Crime, Horror, 1964)
52		Mystery of Edwin Drood (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1935)
52		Diabolique (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1955)
52		Taste the Blood of Dracula (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1970)
52		Dracula's Daughter (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1936)
52		Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (Drama, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1920)
52		The Mummy's Tomb (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1942)
52		Son of Frankenstein (Sci-Fi, Horror, Drama, 1939)
52		The Hidden (Action, Crime, Horror, 1987)
52		Valley of the Zombies (Action, Drama, Horror, 1946)
50		The Lodger (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2009)
50		The Zodiac (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2005)
50		The Flesh and the Fiends (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1960)
50		American Mary (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2012)
50		Resurrection (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1999)
50		Daughter of Darkness (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1948)
50		The Spreading Ground (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2000)
50		The Devil's Muse (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2007)
50		Surveillance (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2008)
50		The Lost (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2006)
49		What Ever Happened to Baby Jane? (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1962)
47		The Psychopath (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1966)
47		Before I Hang (Crime, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1940)
47		Red White & Blue (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2010)
47		Pathology (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 2008)
47		Henry II: Portrait of a Serial Killer (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 1996)
47		The New Kids (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1985)
47		Psycho II (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1983)
47		Byzantium (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2012)
47		House at the End of the Street (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2012)
47		The Gift (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2000)
47		Persecution (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1974)
47		Massacre at Central High (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1976)
47		Bones (Crime, Horror, 2001)
47		Mr In-Between (Crime, Horror, Romance, 2001)
47		The Bells (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1926)
47		The Face at the Window (Drama, Horror, 1939)
45		The Evictors (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1979)
45		Three Cases of Murder (Crime, Mystery, Drama, Horror, 1955)
45		The Town That Dreaded Sundown (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1976)
45		The Last House on the Left (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1972)
45		Strange Confession (Crime, Horror, Drama, 1945)
45		The Road (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2011)
45		The Hand (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1960)
45		The Black Dahlia Haunting (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2012)
45		Dahmer (Biography, Crime, Drama, Horror, 2002)
45		Prison (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1987)
45		Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer (Biography, Crime, Drama, Horror, 1986)
44		I Still Know What You Did Last Summer (Horror, Mystery, 1998)
44		Body Parts (Horror, Thriller, 1991)
44		Saw III (Horror, 2006)
44		Saw II (Horror, Mystery, 2005)
44		Black Sunday (Fantasy, Horror, Thriller, 1960)
44		My Bloody Valentine (Horror, Thriller, 2009)
42		Ruby (Drama, Horror, 1977)
42		Pit and the Pendulum (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1961)
42		The Man Who Could Cheat Death (Drama, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1959)
42		She-Wolf of London (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1946)
42		Starry Eyes (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2014)
42		The Man They Could Not Hang (Crime, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1939)
42		Frankenstein Must Be Destroyed (Horror, Drama, Sci-Fi, 1969)
42		Black Friday (Drama, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1940)
42		The Exorcism of Emily Rose (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2005)
42		Blood and Chocolate (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2007)
42		The Maid (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
42		Behind the Mask (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1932)
42		Green Room (Crime, Horror, Music, 2015)
42		Creature with the Atom Brain (Crime, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1955)
42		Scream for Help (Horror, Mystery, Crime, 1984)
42		Phantom Ship (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1935)
42		The Watcher (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 2000)
42		The Witch Who Came from the Sea (Drama, Horror, Romance, 1976)
42		Cry_Wolf (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
42		The Monolith Monsters (Drama, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1957)
42		The Return of the Vampire (Drama, Horror, 1943)
42		Crypt of Dark Secrets (Crime, Horror, 1976)
42		Eye See You (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 2002)
42		Murders in the Zoo (Crime, Horror, 1933)
42		Split Second (Action, Crime, Horror, 1992)
42		Lady in a Cage (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1964)
42		The Exorcist III (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1990)
42		Heartless (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2009)
42		The Walking Dead (Crime, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1936)
42		The Demon Barber of Fleet Street (Drama, Horror, 1936)
40		Bless the Child (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2000)
40		Ed Gein (Biography, Crime, Drama, Horror, 2000)
40		The Night Stalker (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1986)
40		Act of Vengeance (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1974)
40		Ilsa: She Wolf of the SS (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1975)
40		In the Devil's Garden (Mystery, Crime, Drama, Horror, 1971)
40		Nightmare Honeymoon (Crime, Horror, Drama, 1974)
40		The Killing Kind (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1973)
40		Endless Night (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1972)
40		What the Peeper Saw (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1972)
40		Goodbye Gemini (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1970)
40		Scream and Scream Again (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1970)
40		Don't Turn Out the Light (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1987)
40		The Brain (Crime, Horror, Drama, 1962)
40		The Believers (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1987)
40		Stripped to Kill (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1987)
40		When a Stranger Calls (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1979)
40		The Stepfather (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1987)
40		Ricky 6 (Biography, Crime, Drama, Horror, 2000)
40		Izo (Action, Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2004)
40		Senseless (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2008)
40		Dead Man's Eyes (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1944)
40		Donkey Punch (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2008)
40		Funny Games (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2007)
40		The Killing Gene (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2007)
40		Acolytes (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2008)
40		iMurders (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2008)
40		Nine Dead (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2010)
40		Choose (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2011)
40		Megan Is Missing (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2011)
40		The Coverup (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2008)
40		Le pharmacien de garde (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2003)
40		Whisper (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2007)
40		The Tall Man (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2012)
40		Cheap (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2005)
40		The Bad Seed (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1956)
40		Grimm Love (Crime, Drama, Horror, 2006)
39		Swamp Devil (Horror, 2008)
39		No One Lives (Horror, Thriller, 2012)
39		Doctor Mordrid (Action, Fantasy, Horror, 1992)
39		The Magician (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1926)
39		The Devil-Doll (Sci-Fi, Horror, 1936)
39		The Oblong Box (Horror, 1969)
39		Scanners (Action, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1981)
39		Corruption (Horror, 1968)
39		The Devil Bat (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1940)
39		House of Horrors (Horror, Thriller, 1946)
39		Mad Love (Horror, Romance, Sci-Fi, 1935)
39		Cherry Falls (Horror, Mystery, Romance, 2000)
38		Peeping Tom (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1960)
38		Don't Breathe (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 2016)
37		The Doctor and the Devils (Horror, Drama, 1985)
37		Trouble Every Day (Horror, Thriller, Drama, 2001)
37		Dark Moon Rising (Crime, Horror, Romance, 2009)
37		House of Dark Shadows (Drama, Horror, Romance, 1970)
37		The Last House on the Left (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 2009)
37		The Mad Genius (Drama, Horror, Romance, 1931)
37		Dream No Evil (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1970)
37		Dead Men Walk (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1943)
37		Deadly Friend (Drama, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1986)
37		Scar (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 2007)
37		Condemned to Live (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1935)
37		Jack the Ripper (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1959)
37		Nobody (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 2007)
37		The Attic (Drama, Thriller, Horror, 1980)
37		Shadow of Chinatown (Crime, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1936)
37		Dr. Cyclops (Adventure, Drama, Horror, 1940)
37		Dracula Has Risen from the Grave (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1968)
37		Evilspeak (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1981)
37		A Reflection of Fear (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1972)
37		The Final (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2010)
37		Tattoo (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1981)
37		American Nightmare (Horror, Crime, Thriller, 1983)
37		The Majorettes (Action, Crime, Horror, 1987)
37		The Nurse (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1997)
37		Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1992)
37		Nightwatch (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1997)
37		Fog Island (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1945)
37		Diabolique (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1996)
37		Horns (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2013)
37		Willard (Drama, Horror, Sci-Fi, 2003)
37		Strangler of the Swamp (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1946)
37		Mary Shelley's Frankenstein (Drama, Horror, Romance, 1994)
37		Madhouse (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1974)
37		Sick Girl (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 2007)
37		The Psycho Lover (Crime, Horror, 1970)
37		La settima donna (Drama, Thriller, Horror, 1978)
37		The Devil's Rejects (Crime, Horror, 2005)
37		The Other (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1972)
37		The Black Room (Crime, Horror, 1935)
37		Hide & Seek (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2010)
37		The Woman in Black (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2012)
37		The First Power (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 1990)
37		Girls Against Boys (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2012)
37		Monkey Shines (Drama, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1988)
37		The Invisible Man Returns (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1940)
35		The Manson Family (Crime, Drama, History, Horror, 1997)
34		Horror on Snape Island (Horror, 1972)
34		Wolves (Action, Horror, 2014)
34		J.D.'s Revenge (Action, Horror, Thriller, 1976)
34		The Man Who Laughs (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1928)
34		The Vampire Lovers (Horror, 1970)
34		Annabelle (Horror, Mystery, 2014)
34		Resident Evil: Degeneration (Animation, Action, Horror, 2008)
34		In the Mouth of Madness (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 1994)
34		Creep (Horror, Mystery, 1995)
34		The Spiral Staircase (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1945)
34		Saw IV (Horror, Mystery, 2007)
34		Trauma (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1993)
34		Strangeland (Horror, Thriller, 1998)
34		The Two Faces of Dr. Jekyll (Horror, 1960)
34		Cheshmane John Malkovich 1: Viggo Mortensen (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2004)
34		Valentine (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2001)
34		The Signal (Horror, Sci-Fi, Thriller, 2007)
34		Dead Silence (Horror, 2007)
34		Midnight Ride (Action, Horror, Thriller, 1990)
34		Two Evil Eyes (Horror, 1990)
34		Terminal Choice (Horror, Thriller, 1985)
34		Invitation Only (Horror, Romance, 2009)
34		The Sender (Horror, Thriller, 1982)
34		The Boogey Man (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1980)
34		Night Monster (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1942)
34		StageFright (Horror, 1987)
34		Repo! The Genetic Opera (Horror, Musical, Sci-Fi, 2008)
34		The Soul of a Monster (Horror, 1944)
34		The Invisible Man's Revenge (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1944)
34		Freakdog (Horror, Thriller, 2008)
34		The Silent Scream (Horror, Thriller, 1979)

Notes: Movies similar to The Penalty, Movies like The Penalty, Crime, Drama, Horror, Wallace Worsley, Charles Clary, Doris Pawn, Jim Mason, Lon Chaney, Films, Video, Movie Similarities