74		The Messengers (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2007)
74		The Children (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
63		6 Souls (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
59		They Wait (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2007)
59		You're Next (Horror, Thriller, 2011)
57		11-11-11 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2011)
57		The Exorcism of Emily Rose (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2005)
55		The Darkroom (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
55		The Return (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
55		Trauma (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1993)
55		Sinister 2 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2015)
55		An American Haunting (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2005)
53		My Soul to Take (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
53		Sleepless (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2001)
52		Barricade (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2012)
52		Panic in Year Zero! (Horror, Sci-Fi, Thriller, 1962)
52		Psycho II (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1983)
51		Saw (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
51		The Town That Dreaded Sundown (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
50		Happy Birthday to Me (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1981)
50		Night Watch (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1973)
50		Toolbox Murders (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
50		Road Games (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1981)
50		Nightmare (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1964)
50		The Spiral Staircase (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1945)
50		Berserk (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1967)
50		Klynham Summer (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1982)
50		The Prowler (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1981)
50		Psycho III (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1986)
49		Beneath (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2007)
49		I'll Bury You Tomorrow (Horror, Thriller, Mystery, 2002)
49		The Poughkeepsie Tapes (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2007)
49		House at the End of the Street (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2012)
48		Reaper (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2000)
48		Killer Me (Mystery, Thriller, Horror, 2001)
48		Psych:9 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
48		From Hell (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2001)
48		Valentine (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2001)
48		The Grudge 3 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
47		The Call of Cthulhu (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
47		Like Minds (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 2006)
47		A Reflection of Fear (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1972)
47		Saw II (Horror, Mystery, 2005)
47		The Amityville Horror (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
47		The Other (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1972)
46		Come Back to Me (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
46		Mum & Dad (Horror, Thriller, 2008)
46		Cut! (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
46		Deadly Revisions (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
46		3 Extremes II (Horror, Mystery, 2002)
46		The Canal (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
46		The Hound of the Baskervilles (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1939)
46		The Den (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
46		The Eighteenth Angel (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1997)
46		Open Grave (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
45		Breaking Dawn (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
45		The Night Walker (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1964)
45		The Card Player (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
45		Homicidal (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1961)
45		Friday the 13th Part 2 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1981)
45		Chain Letter (Horror, Thriller, 2009)
45		Creep (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
45		Psycho-Circus (Mystery, Thriller, Horror, 1966)
45		Exorcist: The Beginning (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
45		The Dark (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2005)
45		Fingerprints (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
45		Under Surveillance (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
45		The Last Winter (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
45		The Abandoned (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
45		The Spiral Staircase (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1975)
45		Penny Dreadful (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
45		Turistas (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
45		Tenebre (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1982)
45		The Comeback (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1978)
45		Friday the 13th: A New Beginning (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1985)
45		Friday the 13th (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1980)
45		Black Christmas (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1974)
45		Room 6 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
45		The Inn (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
45		Jennifer's Shadow (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
45		The Zodiac Killer (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1971)
45		The Grudge (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
45		The Dark Half (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1993)
45		Bikini Island (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1991)
45		The Woods (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
45		Salvage (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
45		The Bat (Horror, Thriller, Mystery, 1959)
45		The Skeleton Key (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2005)
45		The New Daughter (Horror, Thriller, 2009)
45		Eternal (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2004)
45		Night Monster (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1942)
45		Cherry Falls (Horror, Mystery, Romance, 2000)
45		The Night Has Eyes (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1942)
45		The Mad Magician (Horror, Thriller, Mystery, 1954)
45		Horror Island (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1941)
44		Blackout (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
44		Darkness Falls (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2003)
44		Kill by Inches (Horror, Thriller, Fantasy, 1999)
44		June 9 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
44		I Can See You (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
44		In Their Skin (Horror, Thriller, 2012)
44		The Strangers (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
44		My Little Eye (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2002)
44		Breathing Room (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
44		Octane (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2003)
44		From Within (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
44		Dead End (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2003)
44		Disturbing Behavior (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 1998)
44		Shutter (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
44		Sinister (Horror, Mystery, 2012)
44		Hangman's Curse (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2003)
44		Farm House (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
44		Left for Dead (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2007)
44		Autopsy (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
44		The Dead Outside (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
44		Woetoli (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
44		Below (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2002)
44		The Collingswood Story (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2002)
44		The Devil's Rejects (Crime, Horror, 2005)
44		They (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2002)
44		100 Feet (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
44		Gothika (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2003)
43		A Nightmare on Elm Street (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
43		Visions (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
43		Srpski film (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
43		Evil Angel (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
43		The Reeds (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
43		Imago mortis (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
43		House of the Damned (Action, Horror, Thriller, 1996)
43		Devil (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
43		Vanishing on 7th Street (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
43		Atrocious (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2010)
43		The St. Francisville Experiment (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2000)
43		Les morsures de l'aube (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2001)
43		The Jailhouse (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
43		Evil Things (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
43		The Shortcut (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
43		Oculus (Horror, Mystery, 2013)
43		Chasing Sleep (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2000)
43		Wendigo (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2001)
43		Curse of Chucky (Horror, Thriller, 2013)
43		Case 39 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
43		Orphan (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
43		Nine Miles Down (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
43		Reminiscence: The Beginning (Horror, Romance, Thriller, 2014)
42		Whoever Slew Auntie Roo? (Horror, Thriller, 1972)
42		The Beast in the Cellar (Horror, Thriller, 1970)
42		Scream for Help (Horror, Mystery, Crime, 1984)
42		Playroom (Horror, Thriller, 1989)
42		Cry_Wolf (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
42		Kolobos (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1999)
42		House on Haunted Hill (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1999)
42		Die! Die! My Darling! (Horror, Thriller, 1965)
42		Madison County (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2011)
42		Strait-Jacket (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1964)
42		Hollow (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2011)
42		The Tunnel (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2011)
42		The Oregonian (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2011)
42		Nursie (Horror, Thriller, 2004)
42		The Pact (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2012)
42		The 4th Floor (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1999)
42		Psycho (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1960)
42		Stir of Echoes (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1999)
42		Psycho (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1998)
42		Urban Legend (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1998)
42		Amber Alert (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2012)
42		Severed Footage (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2012)
42		Bigfoot: The Lost Coast Tapes (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2012)
42		The Psychopath (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1966)
42		Resolution (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2012)
41		The Blood Lands (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
41		Dark Awakening (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
41		Haunter (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
41		Willow Creek (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
41		Evidence (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
41		Inner Demons (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
41		Wrath of the Crows (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
41		Cybernatural (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
41		Eye See You (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 2002)
41		Bela Kiss: Prologue (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
41		Lost Place (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
41		The Taking of Deborah Logan (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
41		House Hunting (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
41		Boogeyman 2 (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2007)
41		Last Shift (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
41		The Thing on the Doorstep (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
41		In Fear (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
41		The Conjuring 2 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2016)
41		Scar (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 2007)
41		Deliver Us from Evil (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
41		Pathology (Crime, Horror, Thriller, 2008)
41		I Know What You Did Last Summer (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1997)
41		Mommy's Day (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1997)
41		The Black Water Vampire (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
41		Murder in the Dark (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
41		The Others (Fantasy, Horror, Thriller, 2001)
41		The Shining (Drama, Horror, 1980)
41		Afflicted (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
41		The Conjuring (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2013)
41		Honeymoon (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)

Notes: Movies similar to The Toybox, Movies like The Toybox, Horror, Mystery, Thriller, Paolo Sedazzari, Alexander Abadzis, Russell Barnes, Suzanne Bertish, Sara Bispham, Films, Video, Movie Similarities