67		Urban Legends: Final Cut (Horror, Mystery, Romance, 2000)
62		I Know What You Did Last Summer (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1997)
61		Curtains (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1983)
60		Sinister (Horror, Mystery, 2012)
60		Bloody New Year (Horror, Mystery, 1987)
60		I Still Know What You Did Last Summer (Horror, Mystery, 1998)
58		Unhinged (Horror, 1982)
58		Shock Waves (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 1977)
58		Final Exam (Horror, 1981)
57		Tourist Trap (Horror, 1979)
57		Ten (Adventure, Horror, Mystery, 2014)
55		The House on Skull Mountain (Horror, Mystery, 1974)
54		Spellcaster (Horror, Mystery, 1988)
53		The Slayer (Horror, 1982)
52		The Haunting (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 1999)
50		The Cat and the Canary (Horror, Mystery, 1927)
50		Wilderness (Horror, 2006)
50		Bikini Island (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1991)
50		The Pool (Horror, Thriller, 2001)
49		Hellbound: Hellraiser II (Horror, Thriller, 1988)
48		Night Warning (Horror, 1982)
48		Humongous (Horror, Romance, 1982)
48		The Burning (Horror, 1981)
48		Midnight (Horror, 1982)
48		Wolfen (Horror, Thriller, 1981)
47		The Supernaturals (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 1986)
47		The Skeleton Key (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2005)
47		Nightmare (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1964)
47		Exeter (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2015)
47		Half Light (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2006)
46		The Hills Have Eyes (Horror, Thriller, 1977)
46		Jason Goes to Hell: The Final Friday (Fantasy, Horror, Thriller, 1993)
46		When a Stranger Calls (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1979)
46		Jack's Back (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1988)
45		Retribution (Horror, Mystery, 1987)
45		Hellraiser (Fantasy, Horror, 1987)
45		Phenomena (Horror, Mystery, 1985)
45		You're Next (Horror, Thriller, 2011)
45		House of Wax (Horror, 2005)
45		Dead Tone (Horror, Thriller, 2007)
45		Survival of the Dead (Horror, 2009)
44		Wolf Creek 2 (Action, Horror, Thriller, 2013)
44		Red Sands (Action, Horror, Thriller, 2009)
44		La casa con la scala nel buio (Horror, Mystery, 1983)
44		Clownhouse (Horror, 1989)
44		Blood Relations (Horror, 1988)
43		Pieces (Horror, Mystery, 1982)
43		The Pit (Horror, Mystery, 1981)
43		Night School (Horror, Mystery, 1981)
43		Graduation Day (Horror, Mystery, 1981)
43		Coma (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1978)
43		Delusion (Horror, 1981)
43		Dead & Buried (Horror, Mystery, 1981)
43		Maniac Cop (Action, Crime, Horror, 1988)
42		The Exorcist III (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1990)
42		Night of Terror (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1933)
42		Witchboard 2 (Horror, Mystery, 1993)
42		Frogs (Horror, Mystery, Romance, 1972)
42		The Mephisto Waltz (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1971)
42		Nothing But the Night (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1973)
42		Cybernatural (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2014)
42		To All a Goodnight (Horror, Mystery, 1980)
42		Screams of a Winter Night (Horror, Mystery, 1979)
42		Inferno (Horror, Mystery, 1980)
42		The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2013)
42		Fog Island (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1945)
42		The Children (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2008)
41		Suspiria (Horror, Mystery, 1977)
41		Creep (Horror, Mystery, 1995)
41		The Wicker Man (Horror, Mystery, 1973)
40		Scream 3 (Horror, Mystery, 2000)
40		The Last Broadcast (Horror, Mystery, 1998)
40		Altar (Horror, Mystery, 2014)
40		Don't Blink (Horror, Mystery, 2014)
40		Annabelle (Horror, Mystery, 2014)
40		Nightlight (Horror, Thriller, 2015)
40		The VVitch: A New-England Folktale (Horror, Mystery, 2015)
40		The Reincarnation of Peter Proud (Horror, Mystery, 1975)
40		Saw V (Horror, Mystery, 2008)
40		The Eye (Horror, Mystery, 2008)
40		The Witchmaker (Horror, Mystery, 1969)
40		Terror in the Wax Museum (Horror, Mystery, 1973)
40		Encounter with the Unknown (Horror, Mystery, 1973)
40		Sorority Row (Horror, Mystery, 2009)
40		Scream (Horror, Mystery, 1996)
40		The Beast Must Die (Horror, Mystery, 1974)
40		Scream 2 (Horror, Mystery, 1997)
40		It Follows (Horror, Mystery, 2014)
40		Deadwood Park (Horror, Mystery, 2007)
40		Island of Blood (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1982)
40		Truth or Die (Horror, Mystery, 2012)
40		Saw IV (Horror, Mystery, 2007)
40		The Deaths of Ian Stone (Horror, Thriller, 2007)
40		The Wizard of Gore (Horror, Mystery, 2007)
40		Scream 4 (Horror, Mystery, 2011)
40		The Ring (Horror, Mystery, 2002)
40		Saw II (Horror, Mystery, 2005)
40		3 Extremes II (Horror, Mystery, 2002)
40		Mirrors (Horror, Mystery, 2008)
40		Spirits of the Dead (Horror, Mystery, 1968)
40		Devil's Due (Horror, Mystery, 2014)
40		Session 9 (Horror, Mystery, 2001)
40		Solstice (Horror, Mystery, 2008)
40		Jeepers Creepers (Horror, Mystery, 2001)
40		Soulmate (Horror, Mystery, 2013)
40		Saw VI (Horror, Mystery, 2009)
40		Final Prayer (Horror, Mystery, 2013)
40		Killer Instinct (Horror, Thriller, 2001)
40		Oculus (Horror, Mystery, 2013)
40		Reeker (Horror, Mystery, 2005)
40		Saw 3D: The Final Chapter (Horror, Mystery, 2010)
40		The Four Skulls of Jonathan Drake (Horror, Mystery, 1959)
40		The Hound of the Baskervilles (Horror, Mystery, 1959)
40		Horrors of the Black Museum (Horror, 1959)
40		The Black Torment (Horror, Mystery, 1964)
40		Hush...Hush, Sweet Charlotte (Crime, Drama, Horror, 1964)
40		Dark Intruder (Horror, Mystery, 1965)
40		Two on a Guillotine (Mystery, Horror, 1965)
40		The Creature Walks Among Us (Horror, 1956)
40		The Beast with Five Fingers (Horror, Mystery, 1946)
40		The Ninth Guest (Horror, Mystery, 1934)
40		Murder by the Clock (Horror, Mystery, 1931)
40		Mark of the Vampire (Horror, Mystery, 1935)
40		The Strange Case of Doctor Rx (Horror, Mystery, 1942)
40		Woman Who Came Back (Horror, Mystery, 1945)
40		I Walked with a Zombie (Fantasy, Horror, 1943)
40		Day of the Nightmare (Horror, Mystery, 1965)
40		Pillow of Death (Mystery, Horror, 1945)
39		R-Point (Action, Horror, War, 2004)
39		American Gothic (Horror, 1988)
39		Pet Sematary (Fantasy, Horror, 1989)
39		The Gift (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2000)
39		Twin Peaks: The Missing Pieces (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2014)
39		Don't Be Afraid of the Dark (Fantasy, Horror, Thriller, 2010)
38		The Comeback (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1978)
37		Mindhunters (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 2004)
37		The Undying Monster (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1942)
37		The Bat (Horror, Thriller, Mystery, 1959)
37		The Most Dangerous Game (Adventure, Horror, Mystery, 1932)
37		Dominique (Horror, 1979)
37		The Shadow of the Cat (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1961)
37		The Maid (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
37		Horror Island (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1941)
37		Lake Mungo (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2008)
37		Night Monster (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1942)
37		Chamber of Horrors (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1940)
37		The Poughkeepsie Tapes (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2007)
37		Case 39 (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
37		Like Minds (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 2006)
37		Dorothy Mills (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2008)
37		Castle of Evil (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 1966)
37		The Stepford Wives (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 1975)
37		Disturbing Behavior (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 1998)
37		Night of Dark Shadows (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1971)
37		The Island (Action, Adventure, Drama, Horror, 1980)
37		Behind the Mask (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1932)
37		The Spiral Staircase (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1945)
36		The Legacy (Horror, 1978)
35		Shallow Grave (Drama, Horror, 1987)
35		Attack of the Beast Creatures (Horror, 1985)
35		Tormented (Horror, Thriller, 1960)
35		Savage Island (Horror, Thriller, 2004)
35		Wrong Turn 6: Last Resort (Horror, 2014)
35		Creature from the Black Lagoon (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1954)
35		It's Alive III: Island of the Alive (Horror, 1987)
35		Nature Morte (Horror, Thriller, 2006)
35		Who Can Kill a Child? (Fantasy, Horror, 1976)
35		The Demon Barber of Fleet Street (Drama, Horror, 1936)
35		Island of Death (Horror, 1976)
35		Attack of the Crab Monsters (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1957)
35		The Reaping (Horror, Thriller, 2007)
35		Crypt of Dark Secrets (Crime, Horror, 1976)
35		Storm Warning (Horror, 2007)
34		Dead of Winter (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1987)
34		Destroyer (Horror, Thriller, 1988)
34		You'll Like My Mother (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1972)
34		Wonder Women (Action, Horror, Sci-Fi, 1973)
34		Vinyan (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 2008)
34		Massacre at Central High (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1976)
34		The Signal (Horror, Sci-Fi, Thriller, 2007)
34		Cabin Fever: Patient Zero (Horror, Sci-Fi, Thriller, 2014)
34		The Nightcomers (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1971)
34		I, Madman (Horror, Thriller, 1989)
34		The Ugly (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1997)
34		The Church (Horror, 1989)
33		Visiting Hours (Horror, Thriller, 1982)
32		The Thing (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 1982)
32		Insensibles (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2012)
32		Ghost Story (Drama, Horror, Thriller, 1981)
32		Island of the Burning Damned (Horror, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 1967)
32		The Shadows (Horror, Mystery, Romance, 2011)
32		Turistas (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2006)
32		Mr. Sardonicus (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1961)
32		Frenchman's Farm (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1987)
32		The Uninvited (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 1944)
32		Isle of the Dead (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 1945)
32		Friday the 13th: A New Beginning (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1985)
32		Nomads (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1986)
32		Ticks (Horror, Sci-Fi, 1993)
32		The Harvest (Drama, Horror, Mystery, 2013)
32		Temnye vody (Horror, 1993)
32		The Secret Life: Jeffrey Dahmer (Biography, Crime, Drama, Horror, 1993)
32		Zombie (Horror, 1979)
32		Morirai a mezzanotte (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1986)
32		Rawhead Rex (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 1986)
32		Angel Heart (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1987)
32		Witchboard (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1986)
32		Manhunter (Crime, Horror, Mystery, 1986)
32		Psycho III (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 1986)
32		The St. Francisville Experiment (Horror, Mystery, Thriller, 2000)

Notes: Movies similar to April Fool's Day, Movies like April Fool's Day, Horror, Mystery, Fred Walton, Deborah Foreman, Griffin O'Neal, Clayton Rohner, Jay Baker, Films, Video, Movie Similarities