52		Candyman (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1992)
50		Puritan (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2005)
45		Youth Without Youth (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2007)
45		No Smoking (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2007)
45		Guantanamero (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2007)
45		The 4th Dimension (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2006)
45		Neverwas (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2005)
45		Where Seagulls Cry a Song (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2009)
45		That Beautiful Somewhere (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2006)
45		The Nines (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2007)
44		The Other Side of the Tracks (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2008)
44		1 and 0 nly (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2008)
44		The Box (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2009)
44		Püha Tõnu kiusamine (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2009)
43		Shuffle (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2011)
43		Lowlife (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2012)
43		Theo (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2010)
43		Dragonfly (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2002)
43		Donovan's Echo (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2011)
43		In Passing (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2011)
42		Deeply (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2000)
42		Big Fish (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2003)
42		The Fallen Word (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2013)
42		O heimonas (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2013)
41		Photographing Fairies (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 1997)
41		Lost River (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2014)
41		The Ghost and Mrs. Muir (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 1947)
41		Winter's Tale (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2014)
40		Pandora and the Flying Dutchman (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 1951)
40		The Halfway House (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 1944)
40		Powder (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 1995)
40		Hereafter (Drama, Fantasy, 2010)
40		Between Two Worlds (Mystery, Drama, Fantasy, 1944)
40		Harlequin (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 1980)
40		The Last Wave (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 1977)
40		The Magus (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 1968)
37		New Nightmare (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 1994)
37		The Invisible (Crime, Drama, Fantasy, 2007)
37		Survive Style 5+ (Fantasy, Mystery, Romance, 2004)
37		The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (Action, Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2003)
36		One Missed Call (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2003)
36		Redentor (Drama, Fantasy, 2004)
35		Bear's Kiss (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2002)
35		Let Me In (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2010)
35		Everybody Says I'm Fine! (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2001)
35		Un jeu d'enfants (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2001)
34		The Zero Theorem (Drama, Fantasy, Sci-Fi, 2013)
33		Desu nôto (Crime, Drama, Fantasy, 2006)
33		Cheshmane John Malkovich 1: Viggo Mortensen (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2004)
33		300 (Action, Drama, Fantasy, 2006)
33		Mamula (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2014)
33		The Way of Snow (Drama, Fantasy, 2008)
33		300: Rise of an Empire (Action, Drama, Fantasy, 2014)
33		Bu neng shuo de. mi mi (Drama, Fantasy, Music, 2007)
33		Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2004)
33		Meet Joe Black (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1998)
33		A Play Entitled Sehnsucht (Fantasy, Mystery, 2012)
32		Hitler Meets Christ (Drama, Fantasy, 2007)
32		Under the Snow (Drama, Fantasy, 2007)
32		Universal Groove (Drama, Fantasy, 2007)
32		Left Behind III: World at War (Action, Drama, Fantasy, 2005)
32		Book of Swords (Action, Drama, Fantasy, 2007)
32		Le domaine perdu (Drama, Fantasy, 2005)
32		Blood and Chocolate (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2007)
32		White Noise 2: The Light (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2007)
32		Koreatown (Action, Drama, Fantasy, 2007)
32		Across the Universe (Drama, Fantasy, Musical, 2007)
32		Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1992)
32		Puffball: The Devil's Eyeball (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2007)
32		Wicked Little Things (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2006)
32		Jai Jagannath (Drama, Fantasy, History, 2007)
32		Constantine (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2005)
32		Whispers from a Shallow Grave (Crime, Fantasy, Mystery, 2006)
32		Audrey Rose (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1977)
32		Time of Her Life (Drama, Fantasy, 2005)
32		Vampire Diary (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2006)
32		Tideland (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2005)
32		Last Mountain (Drama, Fantasy, 2005)
32		The Elk Hotel (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2006)
32		Perfect Creature (Action, Drama, Fantasy, 2006)
32		The Omen (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2006)
32		Silence Becomes You (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2005)
32		A Dream of Color in Black and White (Crime, Drama, Fantasy, 2005)
32		Mr. Nobody (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2009)
32		Return of the Fly (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1959)
32		The Call of Cthulhu (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2005)
32		Perfume: The Story of a Murderer (Crime, Drama, Fantasy, 2006)
32		The Lake House (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2006)
32		The PianoTuner of EarthQuakes (Drama, Fantasy, Music, 2005)
32		Hele sa hiwagang hapis (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2016)
32		Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2011)
32		The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey (Adventure, Fantasy, 2012)
32		Behind the Waterfall (Drama, Fantasy, 1995)
32		Fetching Cody (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2005)
32		The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2008)
32		Lodo (Drama, Fantasy, 2009)
31		The Chosen One (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2009)
31		City of God's Son (Crime, Drama, Fantasy, 2009)
31		Strings (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2004)
31		Neverland (Drama, Fantasy, 2003)
31		Westender (Drama, Fantasy, 2003)
31		Mind Forest (Drama, Fantasy, Thriller, 2003)
31		Koi... Mil Gaya (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2003)
31		Northfork (Drama, Fantasy, 2003)
31		The Cooler (Crime, Drama, Fantasy, 2003)
31		Millennium Actress (Animation, Drama, Fantasy, 2001)
31		Waking Life (Animation, Drama, Fantasy, 2001)
31		The Green Mile (Crime, Drama, Fantasy, 1999)
31		Silver Man (Crime, Drama, Fantasy, 2003)
31		End Game (Action, Drama, Fantasy, 2003)
31		Very Little Time (Fantasy, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 2009)
31		Alithini zoi (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2004)
31		Raspberry & Lavender (Drama, Fantasy, Music, 2004)
31		Tales from Beyond (Drama, Fantasy, Sci-Fi, 2004)
31		Izo (Action, Drama, Fantasy, 2004)
31		The Eye 2 (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2004)
31		Saint Ange (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2004)
31		El cadáver exquisito (Drama, Fantasy, 2011)
31		The Eternal Present (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2004)
31		End (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2009)
31		Around June (Animation, Drama, Fantasy, 2008)
31		Franklyn (Drama, Fantasy, Sci-Fi, 2008)
31		The Time Traveler's Wife (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2009)
31		For the End of Time (Drama, Fantasy, 2009)
31		A Gothic Tale (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2008)
31		20th Century Boys 1: Beginning of the End (Adventure, Fantasy, Mystery, 2008)
31		Suspension (Action, Drama, Fantasy, 2008)
31		Heartless (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2009)
31		The Midnight Meat Train (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2008)
31		Triangle (Fantasy, Mystery, Thriller, 2009)
31		Under the Mountain (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2009)
31		The Blackest Days (Crime, Drama, Fantasy, 2012)
31		The Unborn (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2009)
31		Ink (Action, Drama, Fantasy, 2009)
31		The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus (Adventure, Fantasy, Mystery, 2009)
31		The Melancholy of Socks (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2009)
31		Enter the Void (Drama, Fantasy, 2009)
31		Out of the Fog (Fantasy, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 2009)
31		Sindrome de Pinocchio (Drama, Fantasy, Sci-Fi, 2008)
31		Twilight (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2008)
31		Psychotropica (Action, Drama, Fantasy, 2009)
31		Kashf: The Lifting of the Veil (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2008)
31		Jesus of Macon, Georgia (Drama, Fantasy, 2008)
31		Bathory: Countess of Blood (Biography, Drama, Fantasy, 2008)
31		Valhalla Rising (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2009)
31		Vicino alla Montagna (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2009)
31		Sodium Babies (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2009)
31		Dorian Gray (Drama, Fantasy, Thriller, 2009)
31		A Heavenly Vintage (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2009)
31		The Echo Game (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2009)
31		The Lovely Bones (Drama, Fantasy, Thriller, 2009)
31		The Twilight Saga: New Moon (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2009)
31		From Time to Time (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2009)
31		Invisible Eyes (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2009)
31		The Tale of the Princess Kaguya (Animation, Drama, Fantasy, 2013)
31		Dreams and Shadows (Drama, Fantasy, 2009)
30		Dagon (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2001)
30		The Discovery of Heaven (Drama, Fantasy, 2001)
30		A Espada e a Rosa (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2010)
30		Charlie St. Cloud (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2010)
30		Cyberbully 3 (Drama, Fantasy, 2016)
30		K (Drama, Fantasy, 2002)
30		Queen of the Damned (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2002)
30		Vanilla Sky (Fantasy, Mystery, Romance, 2001)
30		Montagna con Forza (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2002)
30		Time Changer (Drama, Fantasy, Sci-Fi, 2002)
30		Jonah Hex (Action, Drama, Fantasy, 2010)
30		Rabbits (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2002)
30		Cremaster 3 (Drama, Fantasy, 2002)
30		You Are Here (Drama, Fantasy, Sci-Fi, 2010)
30		Ascension (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2002)
30		Double Vision (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2002)
30		Left Behind II: Tribulation Force (Action, Drama, Fantasy, 2002)
30		Revelation (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2001)
30		Insidious (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2010)
30		The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn - Part 1 (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2011)
30		Immortals (Action, Drama, Fantasy, 2011)
30		Hellhounds (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2013)
30		Comforting Skin (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2011)
30		The Melancholy Fantastic (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2011)
30		4:44 Last Day on Earth (Drama, Fantasy, Sci-Fi, 2011)
30		Little Boy Blue (Drama, Fantasy, Thriller, 2011)
30		Transmigration (Adventure, Fantasy, Mystery, 2011)
30		The Twilight Saga: Eclipse (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2010)
30		MSG 2 the Messenger (Drama, Fantasy, 2015)
30		Life of Pi (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2012)
30		Po (Drama, Fantasy, 2016)
30		Closure of Catharsis (Fantasy, Mystery, 2011)
30		La belle et la bête (Fantasy, Romance, 2014)
30		Alien Inhabitant (Crime, Drama, Fantasy, 2011)
30		Bunraku (Action, Drama, Fantasy, 2010)
30		Dead Awake (Fantasy, Mystery, Romance, 2010)
30		The Incubus (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2010)
30		The Wolfman (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2010)
30		Lovelorn (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2010)
30		Passion Play (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2010)
30		Motion Sickness (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2010)
30		Des jeunes gens mödernes (Drama, Fantasy, Musical, 2011)
30		The Mirror Boy (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2011)
30		Embers of the Sky (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2010)
30		The Tree of Life (Drama, Fantasy, 2011)
30		Beastly (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2011)
30		Red Riding Hood (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 2011)

Notes: Movies similar to Lady in the Water, Movies like Lady in the Water, Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, M. Night Shyamalan, Paul Giamatti, Bryce Dallas Howard, Jeffrey Wright, Bob Balaban, Films, Video, Movie Similarities