59		Practical Magic (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 1998)
54		An American Werewolf in Paris (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 1997)
51		Vanilla Sky (Fantasy, Mystery, Romance, 2001)
50		Wristcutters: A Love Story (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2006)
50		La belle et la bête (Fantasy, Romance, 2014)
47		Yolanda and the Thief (Fantasy, Musical, Romance, 1945)
46		Woman on Top (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2000)
44		Platinum Blonde (Fantasy, Romance, 2001)
44		Sex Files: Erotic Possessions (Fantasy, Romance, 2000)
44		Wings of Desire (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1987)
44		Sex Files: Ancient Desires (Fantasy, Romance, 2000)
44		Just Like Heaven (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2005)
43		Castle Eros (Fantasy, Romance, 2002)
42		Alegría (Drama, Romance, Fantasy, 1999)
42		Made in Heaven (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1987)
41		Kate & Leopold (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2001)
41		Always (Fantasy, Romance, 1989)
41		Stairway to Heaven (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 1946)
40		Youth Without Youth (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 2007)
40		Enter the Void (Drama, Fantasy, 2009)
40		Snow White (Fantasy, Romance, 1916)
40		Berkeley Square (Fantasy, Romance, 1933)
40		Akumulátor 1 (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1994)
39		The Wolves of Kromer (Fantasy, Horror, Comedy, 1998)
38		Mr. Destiny (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1990)
38		Ghost (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1990)
37		L'oeil qui ment (Comedy, Fantasy, 1992)
37		A Midsummer Night's Dream (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1968)
37		Death Takes a Holiday (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1934)
37		Gospel According to Harry (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 1994)
37		Ulybka Boga, ili Chisto odesskaya istoriya (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2008)
37		Twilight (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2008)
37		Groundhog Day (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1993)
37		Lovelorn (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2010)
37		Buried Treasure (Adventure, Fantasy, Romance, 1921)
36		Cumulus 9 (Action, Adventure, Fantasy, 1992)
36		Lodo (Drama, Fantasy, 2009)
36		Zhui nui zi 95: Zhi qi meng (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1995)
35		The Nativity Story (Drama, Family, Fantasy, 2006)
35		Bear's Kiss (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2002)
35		Little John (Fantasy, Musical, Romance, 2002)
35		Freedom Deep (Fantasy, 1998)
35		Animals (Drama, Fantasy, 2012)
34		Photographing Fairies (Drama, Fantasy, Mystery, 1997)
34		Love & Plutonium (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2005)
34		Prelude to a Kiss (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1992)
34		Rough Magic (Comedy, Drama, Romance, Fantasy, 1995)
34		Bewitched (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2005)
34		Carnival of Souls (Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, 1962)
34		Love Potion No. 9 (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1992)
34		Mah nakorn (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2004)
34		Alithini zoi (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2004)
34		WillFull (Comedy, Fantasy, 2001)
34		A Life Less Ordinary (Comedy, Crime, Fantasy, 1997)
33		Making Waves (Comedy, Fantasy, 1994)
33		Penelope (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2006)
33		Eve (Adventure, Fantasy, 2002)
33		Portrait of Jennie (Drama, Romance, Fantasy, 1948)
33		The Importance of Being Russell (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2006)
33		Midnight in Paris (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2011)
33		The Purple Rose of Cairo (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1985)
33		The Nine Lives of Tomas Katz (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2000)
32		You're So Cupid! (Family, Fantasy, Romance, 2010)
32		What Dreams May Come (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1998)
32		Boy Meets Girl (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1998)
32		Mirrormask (Adventure, Fantasy, 2005)
32		Dreams Beyond Memory (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1988)
32		It All Came True (Fantasy, Comedy, Romance, 1998)
32		Meet Joe Black (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1998)
32		Simon Magus (Mystery, Fantasy, Romance, 1999)
32		A Midsummer Night's Dream (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1999)
32		Deal of a Lifetime (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1999)
32		A Reading of Tristan & Isolde (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2009)
32		Mannequin (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1987)
32		Beastly (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2011)
32		Angel on My Shoulder (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1946)
32		Twilight of the Ice Nymphs (Fantasy, Mystery, Romance, 1997)
32		Alicja (Fantasy, Musical, Romance, 1982)
32		Liar Liar (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1997)
32		Prince Valiant (Adventure, Fantasy, Romance, 1997)
32		The Addams Family (Comedy, Fantasy, 1991)
32		Lovesick (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1983)
32		Nightfur (Fantasy, Music, Romance, 2011)
32		City of Angels (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1998)
32		Kiss Me Goodbye (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1982)
32		Ratatouille (Animation, Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2007)
32		Mr. Peabody and the Mermaid (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1948)
32		Lyubov v bolshom gorode (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2009)
32		Somewhere in Time (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1980)
31		Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2004)
31		Zus & zo (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2001)
31		What Women Want (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2000)
31		Insatiable Wives (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2000)
31		Naked Wishes (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2000)
31		Kothanodi (Fantasy, 2015)
31		One Hell of a Guy (Romance, Comedy, Fantasy, 2000)
31		Surrender (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2000)
31		Bedazzled (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2000)
31		Everybody Says I'm Fine! (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2001)
31		The 4th Life (Fantasy, Thriller, 2006)
31		Phenomenon (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1996)
31		Big Man on Campus (Comedy, Fantasy, 1989)
31		Mighty Aphrodite (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1995)
31		Stranger Than Fiction (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2006)
31		Dating the Enemy (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1996)
31		To Gillian on Her 37th Birthday (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1996)
30		The Perfect Holiday (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2007)
30		Aquamarine (Comedy, Family, Fantasy, 2006)
30		Treasure Hunt (Action, Fantasy, Romance, 1994)
30		Erik the Viking (Comedy, Adventure, Fantasy, 1989)
30		Celia (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 1989)
30		Faraway, So Close! (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1993)
30		O Lucky Man! (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 1973)
30		Fatty Drives the Bus (Comedy, Fantasy, 1999)
30		Still Breathing (Comedy, Drama, Romance, Fantasy, 1997)
30		Swing (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2003)
30		Koi... Mil Gaya (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2003)
30		Shihaisha no Tasogare (Animation, Fantasy, 1997)
30		Work Is a 4-Letter Word (Comedy, Fantasy, 1968)
30		Being John Malkovich (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 1999)
30		The Mummy's Kiss (Fantasy, Horror, Romance, 2003)
30		I Never Promised You a Rose Garden (Drama, Fantasy, 1977)
30		Night Magic (Fantasy, Musical, 1985)
30		Sucker Punch (Action, Fantasy, 2011)
30		I Walked with a Zombie (Fantasy, Horror, 1943)
30		Everything's Ducky (Comedy, Fantasy, 1961)
30		Lucinda's Spell (Fantasy, 1998)
30		Ren yu chuan shuo (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1994)
30		About Time (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2013)
30		Highlander: The Final Dimension (Action, Fantasy, Romance, 1994)
30		Survive Style 5+ (Fantasy, Mystery, Romance, 2004)
30		The Rocking Horse Winner (Drama, Fantasy, 1949)
29		Simply Irresistible (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 1999)
29		Millennium Actress (Animation, Drama, Fantasy, 2001)
29		Destiny (Crime, Drama, Fantasy, 1944)
29		Sliding Doors (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 1998)
29		Invitation to the Dance (Animation, Fantasy, Musical, 1956)
29		The Others (Fantasy, Horror, Thriller, 2001)
29		The Fifth Province (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 1997)
29		Memorîzu (Animation, Fantasy, Sci-Fi, 1995)
29		Silence Becomes You (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2005)
29		13 Going on 30 (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2004)
29		The Melancholy Fantastic (Drama, Fantasy, Horror, 2011)
29		Fetching Cody (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2005)
29		Un amour de sorcière (Adventure, Comedy, Fantasy, 1997)
29		Dracula (Fantasy, Horror, Romance, 1992)
29		Edward Scissorhands (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1990)
29		Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl (Action, Adventure, Fantasy, 2003)
29		Black Moon (Fantasy, Mystery, Sci-Fi, 1975)
28		Selkie (Adventure, Family, Fantasy, 2000)
28		Alice (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1990)
28		The Price of Milk (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2000)
28		The Lake House (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2006)
28		Baak bin sing gwan (Action, Comedy, Fantasy, 1995)
28		Nothing (Comedy, Fantasy, 2003)
28		Addams Family Values (Comedy, Fantasy, 1993)
28		Just My Luck (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2006)
28		Cremaster 3 (Drama, Fantasy, 2002)
28		Year of the Fish (Animation, Fantasy, Romance, 2007)
28		It's a Boy Girl Thing (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2006)
28		Jit (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1990)
28		A Nightmare on Elm Street 5: The Dream Child (Fantasy, Horror, Romance, 1989)
28		Étoile (Fantasy, Romance, Thriller, 1989)
28		Here Comes Mr. Jordan (Fantasy, Comedy, Romance, 1941)
28		Chances Are (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1989)
28		Telling Tales (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2015)
28		The Time of Their Lives (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1946)
28		Mr. Nobody (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2009)
28		Dead of Night (Fantasy, Horror, Romance, 1945)
28		The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2008)
27		Princess of the Nile (Adventure, Fantasy, Romance, 1954)
27		Thief of Damascus (Adventure, Fantasy, Romance, 1952)
27		Brigadoon (Fantasy, Musical, Romance, 1954)
27		I'll Never Forget You (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1951)
27		Miracle in the Rain (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1956)
27		27, Memory Lane (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2014)
27		Love a la Carte (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2014)
27		Miranda (Fantasy, Comedy, Romance, 1948)
27		The Luck of the Irish (Fantasy, Comedy, Romance, 1948)
27		Song of India (Adventure, Fantasy, Romance, 1949)
27		Helter Skelter (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1949)
27		Bell Book and Candle (Comedy, Romance, Fantasy, 1958)
27		Black Sunday (Fantasy, Horror, Romance, 1960)
27		Aesthetic (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2013)
27		Montagna con Forza (Adventure, Drama, Fantasy, 2002)
27		Beautiful Creatures (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2013)
27		Up Your Teddy Bear (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1970)
27		Blacula (Fantasy, Horror, Romance, 1972)
27		Bedazzled (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1967)
27		Per amore... per magia... (Fantasy, Romance, Musical, 1967)
27		8½ (Drama, Fantasy, 1963)
27		The Fall of the Louse of Usher: A Gothic Tale for the 21st Century (Comedy, Fantasy, Horror, 2002)
27		Reflections of Evil (Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, 2002)
27		Goodbye Charlie (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1964)
27		Waking (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2013)
27		Little Ghost (Family, Fantasy, 1997)
27		The Secret Life of Walter Mitty (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1947)
27		The Mummy (Fantasy, Horror, Romance, 1932)
27		Topper Takes a Trip (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1938)
27		One Million B.C. (Adventure, Fantasy, Romance, 1940)
27		Beyond Tomorrow (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1940)
27		Tom Dick and Harry (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1941)
27		Topper (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1937)
27		Love on the Run (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1936)
27		Adventurous Knights (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1935)
27		The Merry Monarch (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1933)
27		She (Adventure, Fantasy, Romance, 1935)
27		A Midsummer Night's Dream (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1935)
27		Peter Ibbetson (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1935)
27		A Connecticut Yankee (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1931)
27		The Age of Adaline (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2015)
27		Chu-Chin-Chow (Adventure, Fantasy, Romance, 1923)
27		Ali Baba and the Forty Thieves (Adventure, Fantasy, Romance, 1944)
27		Over Her Dead Body (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2008)
27		Sinbad, the Sailor (Adventure, Fantasy, Romance, 1947)
27		Gabriel Over the White House (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1933)
27		Flesh and Fantasy (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1943)
27		I Married a Witch (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1942)
27		The Body Disappears (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1941)
27		I Married an Angel (Fantasy, Musical, Romance, 1942)
27		Kismet (Adventure, Fantasy, Romance, 1930)
27		The Road to Yesterday (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1925)
27		It Had to Be You (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1947)
27		The Exorcism of Hugh (Fantasy, Horror, Romance, 1972)
27		Julia and Julia (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1987)
27		Date with an Angel (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1987)
27		Passion Play (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2010)
27		Charlie St. Cloud (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2010)
27		The Big One (Fantasy, 2005)
27		Embers of the Sky (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2010)
27		Return (Fantasy, Horror, Romance, 1985)
27		Table at Luigi's (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2010)
27		Drawing Restraint 9 (Fantasy, 2005)
27		The Boy Who Could Fly (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1986)
27		Dead Meadow Three Kings (Fantasy, Music, 2010)
27		18 Again! (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1988)
27		Prospero's Books (Drama, Fantasy, 1991)
27		Ghosts of Girlfriends Past (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2009)
27		Thirst (Fantasy, Horror, Romance, 2009)
27		Halfway to Heaven (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2009)
27		The Time Traveler's Wife (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2009)
27		A Heavenly Vintage (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2009)
27		The Girl in a Swing (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1988)
27		Warrior's End (Action, Fantasy, Romance, 2009)
27		The Nutcracker (Fantasy, Music, Romance, 2009)
27		The Invention of Lying (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2009)
27		Legend (Adventure, Fantasy, Romance, 1985)
27		Dead Awake (Fantasy, Mystery, Romance, 2010)
27		L'ange et la femme (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1977)
27		The Bride (Fantasy, Horror, Romance, 1985)
27		Heaven Can Wait (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1978)
27		Xanadu (Fantasy, Musical, Romance, 1980)
27		Upside Down (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 2012)
27		Underworld (Action, Fantasy, Thriller, 2003)
27		Bible! (Fantasy, History, Romance, 1974)
27		La Paloma (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1974)
27		A Matter of Time (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1976)
27		Lian ai kong huang zheng (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2011)
27		Earthbound (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 2012)
27		Time of Her Life (Drama, Fantasy, 2005)
27		Lovespell (Drama, Fantasy, Romance, 1981)
27		The Heavenly Kid (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1985)
27		Splash (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1984)
27		All of Me (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1984)
27		Two of a Kind (Comedy, Fantasy, Romance, 1983)

Notes: Movies similar to Animals with the Tollkeeper, Movies like Animals with the Tollkeeper, Romance, Fantasy, Michael Di Jiacomo, Tim Roth, Mili Avital, Rod Steiger, Mickey Rooney, Films, Video, Movie Similarities