86		Sophie's Curse (Windows, 2016)
85		Shut Eye (Windows, 2016)
73		The Nightfall (Windows, 2018)
57		Imscared (Windows, 2016)
56		Zombie Exodus: Safe Haven (Windows, 2016)
55		Ad Exitum (Windows, 2016)
55		Ultimate Custom Night (Windows, 2018)
54		Boogeyman (Windows, 2015)
54		Stairs (Windows, 2015)
54		FOTD (Windows, 2017)
54		Narcosis (Windows, 2017)
54		BlackShadows (Windows, 2015)
54		Five Nights at Freddy's 4 (Windows, 2015)
54		Perception (Windows, 2017)
54		Corridor 15 (Windows, 2017)
54		Apocalypse: The Game (Windows, 2017)
53		OK/Normal (Windows, 2018)
53		Passing Pineview Forest (Windows, 2014)
53		PT for PC (Windows, 2018)
53		The Occluder (Windows, 2018)
53		Case 2: Animatronics Survival (Windows, 2018)
53		Haunted House: Cryptic Graves (Windows, 2014)
52		Amnesia: The Dark Descent (Windows, 2011)
52		Amnesia: A Machine for Pigs (Windows, 2013)
50		The Void (Windows, 2008)
47		Five Nights at Freddy's: Sister Location (Windows, 2016)
45		NightCry (Windows, 2016)
44		Last Answer (Windows, 2017)
44		Basement (Windows, 2017)
44		Lazaretto (Windows, 2017)
43		Overcast: Walden and the Werewolf (Windows, 2014)

Notes: Games similar to Tattletail, Games like Tattletail, Waygetter Electronics, Little Flag Software, LLC, Windows, Adventure, Contemporary, Survival Horror, Horror, 1st-person, Christmas, PC, Game Similarities.