86		Madden NFL 99 (Windows, 1998)
85		Madden NFL 2000 (Windows, 1999)
85		NFL Blitz (Windows, 1998)
84		Madden NFL 2001 (Windows, 2000)
84		Madden NFL 2003 (Windows, 2002)
83		Madden NFL 97 (DOS, 1996)
83		Madden NFL 2004 (Windows, 2003)
83		Madden NFL 2002 (Windows, 2001)
82		Madden NFL 06 (Windows, 2005)
82		Madden NFL 07 (Windows, 2006)
82		Madden NFL 2005 (Windows, 2004)
81		Madden NFL 08 (Windows, 2007)
80		NFL Football (Windows, 2010)
80		Madden NFL 19 (Windows, 2018)
74		Madden NFL 98 (Windows, 1997)
65		NCAA Football 99 (Windows, 1998)
60		John Madden Football II (DOS, 1991)
60		John Madden Football (DOS, 1989)
52		NFL Quarterback Club 96 (DOS, 1995)
51		ESPN NFL Primetime 2002 (Windows, 2002)
50		Axis Football 2018 (Windows, 2018)
50		Axis Football 2017 (Windows, 2017)

Notes: Games similar to NFL GameDay 99, Games like NFL GameDay 99, 989 Studios, Sony Computer Entertainment America, Inc., Windows, Sports, Bird's-eye view, Football, American, 2D scrolling, NFL, PC, Game Similarities.