45		Wonderland Adventures (Windows, 2007)
44		Zeal (Windows, 2008)
43		Wonderland Adventures: Mysteries of Fire Island (Windows, 2009)
43		Jetsetter (Windows, 2009)
43		Big City Adventure: New York City (Windows, 2009)
42		Make Room for Mush (Windows, 2010)
41		Valhalla Classics: Episode 10 - Village of Evesland (Windows, 2003)
41		Valhalla Classics: Episode 7 - The Gallery (Windows, 2003)
41		Valhalla Classics: Episode 12 - Fortress Tower (Windows, 2003)
41		Valhalla Classics: Episode 8 - Royal Chambers (Windows, 2003)
41		Valhalla Classics: Episode 9 - Edge of Eveswood (Windows, 2003)
41		Valhalla Classics: Episode 11 - Fortress Courtyard (Windows, 2003)
40		Blue Code (DOS, 1991)
40		Taiyō no Shinden (Windows, 2017)
40		Vampiric Tower (DOS, 2000)
40		Beyond the Sunset (Windows, 2017)
40		Valhalla Classics: Episode 1 - The Crypt (Windows, 2001)
40		Kajko i Kokosz: W Krainie Borostworów (DOS, 1997)
40		Valhalla Classics: Episode 2 - The Sanctuary (Windows, 2002)
40		Kajko i Kokosz: W Krainie Borostworów (Windows, 1997)
40		Valhalla Classics: Episode 6 - The Dungeons (Windows, 2002)
40		Valhalla Classics: Episode 5 - The Servants Hall (Windows, 2002)
40		Valhalla Classics: Episode 4 - The Tower (Windows, 2002)
40		Valhalla Classics: Episode 3 - The Chapel (Windows, 2002)

Notes: Games similar to Mystery of Shark Island, Games like Mystery of Shark Island, PlayFirst, Inc., PlayFirst, Inc., Windows, Adventure, Hidden object, Puzzle elements, Top-down, Playground, PC, Game Similarities.